Creep You to Sleep

I Was Locked in a Prison Mine in Connecticut. Something in the Rock Talked Back.

Connecticut, USA · 2026-11-20

Watch on YouTube (subscribe there for a new story every night)

In 1780 a Hartford printer was lowered into the old Simsbury copper mine at Newgate for refusing to name the author of a pamphlet. On the worst night of his first winter, a dry old voice came through a hole in the rock and asked if he played chess.

This story is fiction, set against real places and real history.

Prefer to read it? Download the bedtime PDF (free to share, never to sell).

The real history behind the story

7 facts, each with its source

Old New-Gate Prison and Copper Mine (East Granby, Connecticut)

  • Copper was discovered on Talcott Mountain, then part of Simsbury, in 1705; mining began in 1707, and 64 town residents formed the first chartered copper mining company in America, using its revenues to pay town expenses and hire a schoolmaster.
    Source: connecticuthistory.org
  • Old New-Gate is a National Historic Landmark recognized as the first chartered copper mine and first state prison in the nation, and is run by the state as a museum.
    Source: portal.ct.gov
  • In 1773 Connecticut's General Assembly chose the Simsbury copper mines as the colony's first prison, naming it Newgate (often spelled New-Gate), apparently in emulation of London's notorious Newgate Prison.
    Source: ebsco.com
  • The first inmate arrived on December 22, 1773, and only 18 days later became the first to escape, reportedly with outside help: a woman is believed to have dropped a rope down the 67-foot eastern shaft.
    Source: connecticuthistory.org
  • Connecticut deliberately did not classify convicted Loyalists held at Newgate as prisoners of war, to prevent them from being exchanged and released.
    Source: digitalfarmington.org
  • On May 18, 1781, the largest mass breakout in New-Gate's history occurred when prisoners, including Loyalists, rushed the guards as the hatch was raised to admit a prisoner's wife; one guard was killed, others wounded, and about 20 escaped, 16 of whom were recaptured within a week.
    Source: connecticuthistory.org
  • The site held inmates during the Revolutionary War, became the state prison in 1790, and served as the state's prison for men until 1827, when the new prison opened in Wethersfield.
    Source: portal.ct.gov

The legends

4 told as legend, not fact

These are told locally or were reported long ago but could not be confirmed. The story uses them as legend, not fact.

  • A 1781 London cutaway etching labels a strong trap door as 'the descent to Hell' and calls the underground area 'The prison commonly called Hell.'
  • It is said that in 1774 two prisoners tried to escape by moving rocks in an abandoned ore shaft and were allegedly buried alive when the rocks caved in.
  • Accounts say that on the night before the prison closed in 1827, a convicted counterfeiter fell to his death when his rope broke as he climbed a shaft during an escape attempt.
  • Some accounts give a different date (May 12) and higher figures for the 1781 breakout, with as many as six guards killed and 22 to 30 escapees.

Transcript

Read the full story

I am seventy years old this winter, and I owe my life to a man I never saw.

I have said that sentence to perhaps four people in forty years. My wife heard it once and let it go. My journeyman heard it last spring and laughed, thinking I meant God. I did not mean God. I meant the voice in the rock under Copper Hill, and I am setting it down now, in my own shop in Hartford, because my hands still remember how to set type in the dark and I do not know how many winters they have left.

In November of seventeen-eighty I was twenty-eight, a journeyman compositor with a good place at a print shop near the river in Hartford. I had steady hands and a fair name. That autumn I set and pulled, which is to say printed, an unsigned broadside asking Connecticut to make terms and stop the killing. When the Council of Safety, the Governor's wartime council, asked who wrote it, I told them a printer does not give up his author. I believed that. I still do. They sent me to Newgate to think it over.

They took me out of Hartford in a farm cart with a militia corporal on the seat and my ankles ironed to a ring bolt. We went north on the Simsbury road through Windsor, past cut cornfields and stone walls going grey in the cold, and it took us the best part of the day. The corporal did not talk. The horse did not hurry.

Tray followed the cart.

He was a brindle dog, long in the leg, with one ear that never stood. I had left him tied in the yard behind the shop. He had chewed the rope through. Somewhere past Windsor I saw him behind us, trotting in the wheel rut with his head low, and the corporal saw him too and said nothing. I called to him to go home. He sat down in the road. When the cart had gone on a hundred yards, he got up and followed again.

I was proud that day. I am not proud of it now, but I was. I thought I would be home inside a month, and the dog would have a story to go with his bad ear.

Copper Hill is a long ridge above the Farmington valley. The prison sat on top of it in a stockade, with a guardhouse and a few sheds, and nothing in it looked like a jail. The jail was underneath. The men who chose the place named it Newgate, after the London prison, it was said, and the folk round about had other names for it that I will not write.

The guard who took me off the cart was Enoch Kirk. He was a broad man, built like a miller, with a soft way of speaking that made you lean in to catch it. He unlocked my ankles from the cart and locked them to each other. Then he looked past me at the dog sitting by the stockade gate.

"Yours?"

"He'll go home."

"They mostly don't," he said, kindly enough.

He walked me to a timber shed. In the floor was a heavy hatch on iron hinges, and under it a square black shaft with a ladder going down into a cold breath that smelled of wet stone and old smoke. Kirk went first with a lantern. I went after him, slow, the chain catching on every rung. Water ran down the ladder. Water ran down the walls. By the bottom my sleeves were soaked to the elbow and the light above me was the size of a pocket handkerchief.

The mine kept the same chill winter and summer, about fifty-two degrees. You never got warm in it and you never got dry.

Kirk took me past the main cavern, where I heard men coughing and somebody singing low, and into a narrower passage running north. The roof came down. The floor went up in rough steps. At the end was a dead space with a plank platform against the wall, a slop bucket, and the lantern's light showing every surface wet.

"North drift," Kirk said, which is what miners call a passage driven level into the rock. "You'll have it to yourself."

"Why to myself?"

He set the lantern on a ledge and took his time answering.

"Last man in it fell," he said. "Off the ladder. In the dark." He smiled at me as if we had settled a small matter of business. "So you'll want to stay off the ladder."

He took his lantern and went. I heard his steps go back toward the cavern, and then I heard nothing for a long while but water.

I sat on the platform in my wet coat and told myself it was a hard place and I was a stubborn man and I would bear it.

Then, somewhere close to my right shoulder, in the solid rock, somebody coughed. A small, dry cough. The cough of an old man clearing his throat before he speaks.

I waited. Nobody spoke.

Sound carries strange in a mine, I told myself. It was one of the men in the cavern. I lay down on the planks and pulled my coat over my head, and I did not think of it again for nearly two months.

The keeper came down in the morning. I knew it was morning only because the hatch banged open somewhere above and a grey smudge appeared far back along the passage, and a lantern came bobbing toward me with two men behind it.

The first was Captain Abner Trask. He was thin and stooped from the low roof, with a militia coat gone shiny at the cuffs and a face that looked as if it had not slept well in a year. He held a small book against his chest the way a parson holds a psalter.

"Thorne. Printer. Hartford." He did not ask. He said it to the book.

"Yes, sir."

"You'll be fed once a day. Bread and water come down the shaft in a bucket on a rope, mid-morning. Meat when there's meat. Your slops go up the same way. You'll be given a candle on Sundays, when there are candles." He turned a page. "The ladder is drawn up at sundown. The hatch is shut and barred over it. Nobody comes down and nobody goes up until it's light. Any man found on that ladder after dark is escaping, and will be treated as escaping."

"And the man who had this drift before me?"

He looked up for the first time. His eyes were tired but not unkind.

"Bell. Schoolmaster out of Litchfield. He fell in March, climbing in the dark." He tapped the book. "I wrote it down myself."

He said it the way a man reads off a bill of lading. Then he went back up the passage and took the light with him.

The second man stayed. He was old, bent, with a white stubble and one hand cupped behind his left ear as if he were forever listening for something a long way off.

"Tom Cross," he said, too loud. "Houses. Other men's houses, mostly." He grinned. He had four teeth. "You'll want to sit on your hands to warm them. Not your feet. Feet are lost by Christmas anyhow."

I asked him how long he'd been down.

"Since seventy-six. Ten years for a burglary, and they've lost count of it." He squinted at me. "You heard what the captain said about the ladder?"

"Don't climb it after dark."

"No." He came nearer, so that I could smell the wet wool on him and the tallow in his beard. "That's what the captain says. What I say is, don't take it at night. Not for any reason. Not if the hatch is open. Not if it's let down to you nice and gentle. Not if your own mother calls down it." He nodded toward the plank platform. "The schoolmaster was a careful man. Folded his coat. Counted his crumbs. Careful men don't go up wet rungs in the black." He tapped his cupped ear. "And I sleep near the foot of that shaft. I'm deaf, but I'm not that deaf. He never called out."

"Then what happened to him?"

Tom shrugged with his whole body.

"He took the ladder at night," he said, and went off whistling.

I thought him a cracked old man. I told myself so for some days.

The first week I counted. I scratched the days into the plank with the edge of my iron, seven marks in a row, and I composed in my head the letter I would write to the Council when they sent for me. I set it in imaginary type, line by line, and corrected the spacing. It was a very good letter.

The second week I counted.

Somewhere in the third week, a guard on the rope shouted down that there was snow on Copper Hill a foot deep, and I realized I could not say whether it was the nineteenth day or the twenty-first. I had missed a mark. Or made two. I sat with my thumb on the scratches in the dark, going along them like a line of type, and could not find the fault.

I stopped counting after that.

What I had instead was Tray.

Every morning, before the bucket, before any voice, the hatch would scrape open far above, and with the grey light came a faint sound I learned to wait for. A dog's bark. High, thin, cracked with cold. Three or four of them, then quiet. Somebody up there was letting him near the shed when the hatch was raised. I never knew who. I would lie on the planks with my eyes shut and count his barks, since I had nothing else left to count, and tell myself he was fed.

By Christmas there was no letter. There was no word from the Council. A guard told Tom, who told me, that the Assembly had other matters before it, and that peace printers were not one of them.

I believe it was the first week of January when I understood that nobody was coming for me at all, and that I did not know how long I would be down there, and that the war might outlast me.

That same week, one morning, the hatch opened, and the grey light came, and Tray did not bark.

I waited for the bark all that morning. The bucket came down at its usual hour, swinging and knocking against the shaft wall, and I heard Tom take his loaf and somebody else take theirs, and then the guard called my name and I went up the passage to get mine.

It was Kirk on the rope. I could tell by the voice, soft and unhurried, coming down that wet chimney of stone.

"Thorne. Bread."

I took the loaf out of the bucket. I asked him whether he had seen my dog.

There was a pause up there, long enough that I thought he had gone.

"Haven't," he said. The rope went up.

I carried the loaf back to the north drift and set it on the plank and did not eat it. I did what I did every day by then, which was the only thing that kept me sane. I sat on the edge of the platform, held my left hand out as if it held a composing stick, and set type with my right.

Every piece of type has a nick cut into its shank, a little groove, and a good compositor feels for it with his thumb so the letter goes in right way up without his ever looking down. I had set by bad candlelight half my working life. Down there I set by none. I set the Twenty-third Psalm. I set the bill for a horse auction in Wethersfield I'd done the spring before. I set the broadside that had put me there, all of it, every letter wrong-reading and every line upside down, the way it lies in the stick, and minded my p's and q's, which are mirror images and the first trap for any apprentice. My thumb found nicks that were not there. My hand knew the weight of every line.

That day I could not finish a single sentence. I kept stopping to listen for a bark.

The ladder came up at sundown. I heard it go, rung by rung, a dragging knock, and then the hatch came down and the bar went across it with a sound like a door shut on a church. After that there was only the water.

I could not stay on the plank. I got up in the black and felt my way down the passage with one hand on the wall and the chain between my ankles clinking on the steps, out into the cavern, toward the shaft. I wanted to stand under it. I do not know what I thought I would hear through a foot of oak and a bar of iron. A scratch. A whine. Anything.

I stood with my face turned up to the dark where the hatch was, and water ran into my eyes.

"Come away from there."

It was Tom, from his place against the wall. I had not known he was awake.

"I'm only listening."

"I know what you're doing. I've seen men do it." His voice was low for once. "You stand there long enough, you start to hear it open. Come away."

I went back. I am not sure why I obeyed him, except that he sounded more frightened than I had ever heard him, and he was not a man who frightened easily.

In the north drift I lay down on the plank on my right side, facing the wall, with my coat pulled up to my ears. The wet came through the wool the way it always did. I lay there a long time.

Then I heard the cough.

The same one. Small and dry, an old man's throat being cleared, very near my face, in the rock.

I lay still. I did not breathe. It came again, softer.

I put out my hand. The wall was cold and slick, and pocked all over, as I had long since learned, with the old drill holes the copper miners bored to take their blasting powder. None was wider than my thumb, and most went in a hand's length and stopped. But at the height of my shoulder my fingers found something else, a round mouth in the rock about as wide as my fist, where some charge had blown out a pocket and opened a crack beyond it, and when I pushed my hand into it up to the wrist I felt nothing at the end. Only air. Cold air, moving very faintly toward me, the way it does from a cellar door left open.

I took my hand out.

"Do you play chess?"

It came out of the hole as plainly as if the man were sitting at the foot of my plank. A dry voice. An older man's. Patient, and a little amused, as though he had been waiting some while to ask.

And after it, a sound I knew from the back room of a Hartford coffee house. A click. Then another. Stone pieces being set down on a board, one, two, three, in no hurry at all.

I want to be exact about this. I was awake. I was cold through. My hand was still wet from the hole. And there was no lamp, no candle, no glow of any kind on the other side of that rock, and a man cannot set pieces on a board in a darkness like that one. I could not see my own hand.

"No," I said. My voice came out cracked. "I don't play. I've no board. No light."

The clicking stopped.

I lay there with my heart going. The water dripped. Somewhere in the cavern Tom snored and broke off and snored again.

I should have stopped there. I have thought so many times. But I had spoken to no one but Tom and a rope in seven weeks, and I could not bear for that voice to go.

"Where are you?" I said into the hole.

A small cough first. Then the voice again, mild as milk.

"The east drift, I believe they call it." A pause. "Next door, you might say."

Then a last click, very soft, as of one piece being put away, and nothing more that night but the water.

In the morning there was a paper in my bread.

It was folded small and pushed into a split in the crust, and I nearly bit it. I carried the loaf to the foot of the shaft, where the grey came down from the open hatch, and held the scrap up to that light and made out a few words in a plain round hand.

Your dog is at the guardhouse. I feed him. The men did not like the barking so I keep him by my door now. He is well. R. Pike, cook.

Tom told me who she was. A widow, Ruth Pike, hired on to cook and wash for the guards, the way a woman alone earned her bread in those days. Sharp-tongued, he said. Feeds anything that sits still.

I stood under that shaft holding the paper until the bucket went back up. Then I said to the empty light, out loud, like a fool, "I'll walk you home, Tray. Every mile of the Simsbury road." I meant it as a promise. I did not know yet what it would cost to keep.

That night I gave the voice its answer.

I scratched a board into the end of my plank with the edge of my leg iron, eight squares by eight, feeling the lines as I cut them. For pieces I picked chips out of the wall and floor: the green copper ore for my side, the pale spar for his, soft white stuff that ran in the cracks, which took a notch as easy as lead, though he would never touch them. I filed notches into each one with the iron, the way type is nicked. One for a pawn, two for a knight, a cross for the king. My thumb learned them in an evening. I could have set up that board blind drunk.

"I'll play," I said into the hole.

A small cough. Then the clicks, unhurried, as he laid out his own pieces in a dark as black as mine.

He played the way an old man walks, never hurrying. He named his moves plain, knight to the bishop's third, and waited for mine. He taught me the moves first, the knight's crooked step and the pawn that takes sideways, and he beat me nine nights out of ten that winter. It was a month before I lasted forty moves against him.

One night in the second week he had me. My king was boxed in a corner, and I told him I'd tip it over and save us both the trouble.

A small cough. "Why resign? Let him earn his victory."

I played on out of spite. Four moves later he put his queen where my knight could fork it, and I saw it before he did. He laughed until he coughed.

"There," he said. "Earned."

I lay awake a long time afterward, grinning like a boy. It was the first night since November that I had not listened for the hatch.

Kirk was on the rope the next morning. I took my loaf. There was no paper in it.

"That dog of yours," he said, soft as ever. "Still hanging about the gate."

"Mistress Pike keeps him."

"Mistress Pike." He let the rope go slack. "A dog that barks at a prison gate, nights. Somebody could drown that in the rain barrel, and nobody would think twice."

The bucket went up.

That night, when I put my mouth to the hole and said good evening, the Neighbor did not answer. I sat by the board with my thumb on the cross-notched king until morning, listening, and heard nothing but the water.

He came back the next night.

I had nearly given up on him. I had set the pieces out anyway, by habit, ore on my side and spar on his, and was lying with my knuckles against the cold mouth of the hole when the cough came, small and dry, as if he were embarrassed.

"Good evening," the voice said.

"Where were you?"

A pause. The drip of water on the step below my feet.

"We had company," he said. "Your move, I think. You had the first move last time. I'll have it tonight."

I did not understand him then. I thought he meant some other prisoner, some guard on his side of the rock. I let it go, because he had already pushed his king's pawn two squares, I heard the click of it, and I wanted the game more than I wanted the answer.

We played most of that week. He beat me twice and I beat him once, and the time I beat him I think he let me. He remembered everything. Every bad move I had made since the first night, he could name back to me, the square and the piece, and laugh at it. He laughed at my plans too. I would set up some great slow attack on his king's side, and he would wait until it was nearly ready and then say, quite gently, "That's very pretty," and take a pawn I had left hanging on the other side of the board.

On the fifth or sixth night I asked him about Bell.

"Did you play with the man before me? The schoolmaster?"

The clicking stopped. I waited. I could hear him breathing, or thought I could, a faint dry whistle in the hole.

"Bishop takes knight," he said.

I asked again. He named the move again, exactly the same, in exactly the same voice, as though I had not heard it the first time. I moved his bishop and took my own knight off the board, and did not ask a third time.

That same night, late, I was falling asleep in the middle of a game. My thumb kept losing its place on the notches. He said something and I could not hold it.

"Knight to king's bishop's third," he said again, patient.

"In the morning," I said. "I can't see the board in my head anymore. I'll move it for you in the morning."

"As you like."

I slept.

When the bucket woke me I sat up and put my hand out to the board, to find my place before he spoke again. My fingers went across the spar pieces one by one. Pawn, pawn. Rook in its corner. And then two notches, a knight, standing on the king's bishop's third square.

I had not moved it. I am as sure of that as I am of anything in my life. I had left it on its own back rank. I remember the feel of my thumb on it as I lay down.

I took my hand away. I put it back. The knight was still there.

I told myself I had done it in my sleep. A tired man does things. My fingers knew that board so well by then they might move a piece without me. That was what I said to myself while I ate my bread, with my back to the wall and my eyes on the black where the hole was.

It happened again three nights later. A pawn, that time, on the square he had called just before I dropped off. And once more the week after, a rook.

On the Sunday a candle came down at last, the first since I had arrived. A guard sent it down in the bucket with a tinderbox, flint and steel and a pinch of charred rag in the tin, a thin tallow candle no longer than my finger, and I sat on the floor with my back to the platform and lit it, and for the first time since November I saw my own hands. They were grey. The nails were black. I did not know them.

I knocked a spar pawn off the board reaching for the candle, and it rolled under the plank. I lay on my side on the wet stone to feel for it.

The underside of the platform was scratched.

I had never thought to put my hand there. I held the candle under it and looked up, and there were lines cut into the old wood, deep and careful, as though somebody had done it with a nail over a long time. Eight squares by eight. A chessboard. And beside it, smaller, a column of words and marks.

I lay there with tallow running onto my wrist and made it out.

At the top, in a schoolmaster's tight hand: Rations by order of the Assembly. One pound beef a man a week.

Below that, a row of weeks. Each one a short scratch. Through almost every scratch, a line struck across, and beside each struck line a single word: none.

At the bottom of the column, cut deeper than anything else, as if the hand had pressed hard: E. K. sells it on the Hartford road. Tom has seen the cart. To the Captain, at the first chance.

Enoch Kirk.

I lay under that plank until the candle was half gone. Then I moved it along to the chessboard. Bell had scratched a game there too, the moves listed in a column, short and neat, the way you would set down an exercise for a pupil. I followed them. White to king's pawn four. Black the same. Knight out. On and on. It was a long game. Toward the end the moves came further apart, and the scratches went shallow, like a man's hand that has stopped caring.

The last line said only: I have resigned. He would not let me. I resigned anyway.

There was a date under it. The first week of March.

The keeper's book said Bell fell in March.

I blew out the candle. I could not bear the light on those words. I lay in the dark under the plank with the spar pawn in my fist and the board above my face, and I said into the drift, not to the hole, not to anyone, "Who wouldn't let him?"

The water dripped.

Then, from the hole above me, the small dry cough. And nothing after it.

Kirk came down that Tuesday.

It was an hour after the bucket. I heard the ladder go down the shaft, though no ladder ever went down at that hour, and then his tread in the cavern, heavy, slow. A thin line of yellow came along the passage. He had the lantern shuttered nearly shut, so only a single blade of light showed, and he walked behind it like a man in a dark church.

"Thorne."

"Mister Kirk."

He did not answer. He stood at the mouth of the north drift and let the blade of light go slowly over the walls. Over the slop bucket. Over the plank. It stopped on my board, the green and pale chips on their scratched squares, and stayed there.

"Chess," he said softly. "Who've you got to play chess with, down here?"

"Myself."

"Yourself." He came in. He set the lantern on the step and crouched, and his big hand went flat on the top of the plank, and then slid, slow, toward the edge. Toward the underside.

I did not breathe.

His hand stopped. He looked at me with the light below his face.

"The schoolmaster used to talk to himself as well," he said. "Toward the end."

Then he stood, and took the lantern, and went.

He came again on Friday. And the Sunday after, at an hour I could not name, long after the ladder should have been drawn up, I woke to that same thin blade of light lying across the floor of the drift, and the shape of him behind it, standing perfectly still, watching me sleep.

All that while, the hole in the rock beside my head said nothing at all.

I lay still and let him look. I kept my breathing slow, the way a sleeping man breathes. The blade of light lay on the floor between us for a long time, and then it lifted, and swung, and came to rest on the board at the end of the plank.

He stepped in. I heard the stone grit under his boots. His shadow went up the wall, huge, and bent at the roof.

He did not hurry. He picked the pieces up one at a time, ore and spar, and dropped them into his coat pocket. I heard each one click against the last. When the board was bare he stood a while longer.

"Gaming's against the rules," he said quietly. He knew I was awake. He had known all along.

I sat up. "There's no rule about it."

"There is now." He shut the lantern down to a thread. "The schoolmaster had a talking wall, too. You know that? Told me so himself. Said the rock played chess with him." I heard him smile. "That was the week before his accident."

He went out. I heard the ladder creak under his weight going up, and the hatch, and the bar.

Tom had come up the passage after him. "He's been down three times this month," he said. "Nights."

"I know."

"That's not a thing a guard does," Tom said, and turned over.

In the morning I asked the man on the rope to send for the keeper. I asked politely. I asked twice. Near noon Captain Trask came down, stooping under the roof with his book against his chest, and stood at the mouth of my drift with the lantern held high.

"You wanted me, Thorne."

"Mister Kirk comes down after the ladder's drawn, sir. At night. He took my chessmen."

"Chessmen."

"Stones. I made them."

He looked at the bare board scratched into the plank and something tired moved in his face. Not unkindness. Something worse. Patience.

"Mister Kirk has the night watch. If he goes down, he goes down with my leave." He turned a page in the book without looking at it. "I'll not lose sleep over a handful of pebbles."

"And the beef, sir." My mouth was dry. "The Assembly's ration. We've had none since November."

"Every man down here has told me a guard robbed him," Trask said. "Every man. Thirty of them. The beef comes when the Assembly pays for it, and the Assembly pays late. It is a war, Thorne."

I had the words in my throat. There's proof, sir. Under this plank. A dead man's hand. And then I saw the blade of yellow light lying along the passage floor behind him. Kirk was at the mouth of the cavern with his own lantern, standing easy, waiting for his captain.

I shut my mouth.

"Is there anything else?"

"No, sir."

Trask nodded and went. Kirk let him pass and stood a moment longer, looking up the passage at me. Then he followed.

That afternoon I sat by Tom near the foot of the shaft, where a little grey still came down, and asked him about the east drift.

He was quiet for a long time. I thought he had not heard. Then he cupped his ear toward me and said, "Who's been asking you about that?"

"Nobody. I'm asking."

"The schoolmaster asked me." He picked at a scab on his hand. "Last winter. Same as you. Same face as you've got."

"What did you tell him?"

"What the miners used to tell. I had it from an old fellow who worked these drifts when I was a boy." He leaned in. His breath smelled of wet bread. "Back when it was copper and not men, there was a roof fall in the east drift. Big one. Came down in the night with men under it. Some say three, some say five. They dug a while and heard knocking, and then they didn't hear knocking, and they walled it up and went on with the work. That's the story." He sniffed. "The miners wouldn't eat their dinners near that wall after. Said you could hear them in there. Tapping. Passing the time."

"That's an old tale."

"Is it." He looked at me sideways. "The schoolmaster said that too."

I went back to my drift. I want to be honest about what I thought, because I have had forty years to be ashamed of how hard I worked at it. I thought: there is a man in the east drift. A real man. Kept off the books. Some Tory officer, maybe, or some poor soul the Council wants forgotten. That was why I never heard his bucket. That was why he went quiet when Kirk came. He was afraid of Kirk the same as I was. It was a good, solid, sensible thought, and I built it like a wall and leaned on it.

That night I put my mouth to the hole.

"They took the pieces."

The cough. Then the voice, mild as ever. "I heard."

"We were in the middle."

"Then we'll go on in the middle." A pause, as if he were settling himself. "You can hold a board in your head, printer. You've held whole pages there. Give me your position."

I had never told him what my trade was.

I said nothing about it. I gave him my side, square by square, the way I would read off a forme, which is the page of type locked up tight for the press. Ore king on his own square. Ore rook on the queen's file. Pawns on the third rank, one pushed to the fourth. He corrected me once. I had forgotten a pawn. He was right.

Then he gave me his side, every spar piece, without a pause.

"Your move," he said.

I sat in the black with my hand on the bare scratched board, feeling the empty squares. I knew what I meant to do. I had been planning it for days, ever since Tuesday. Bring the queen's rook across to the king's side, slowly, behind the pawns, where he would not look for it. I had not said a word of it aloud. I had not so much as touched the rook.

"Well," the Neighbor said gently. "Go on, then. Bring the rook across. You've been wanting to since Tuesday."

The water dripped on the step below my feet.

I did not move the rook. I sat there until I could not feel my hands, and he waited, patient, and did not say another word until I did.

I moved the rook on the third night after that. Not because I wanted to. Because I could not bear sitting there with it in my head, knowing he could see it.

"Ah," he said. "There it is." And he answered it with a pawn, as if he had been holding that pawn ready since Christmas.

We finished that game in the dark, and he won it. Then he said, 'Set them up,' and there was nothing to set up, and we began another anyway. By the thaw I had played a dozen games start to finish without a stone to touch. I lost most of them. I lost them all in my head.

That was how we went on. A move a night, sometimes two. Sometimes none, when he would not speak, and I would sit with my knuckles against the cold lip of the hole and hear only water, and know that somewhere in the tunnels there was a shuttered lantern moving.

I started listening the way I used to listen for Tray. I listened at bucket time, mornings. The rope came down the shaft and knocked into the cavern and the guard called names, mine among them, and the rope went up. Then it was done. In all those mornings I never once heard a bucket go anywhere near the east drift. Never heard a guard call into it. Never heard a chain drag on that side of the rock, though every man down there dragged a chain.

"Who feeds you?" I asked him one night.

"I manage."

"There's no bucket. I've listened."

"Then you've listened very carefully." He coughed. "Queen to her bishop's fourth. Mind your king."

Another night I asked him what he could see over there, if he had a candle.

"There's a vein above where I lie," he said. "Green. Running in the rock, about the width of two fingers. It goes from the floor at the far end up across the roof, right over my head, and down again by the hole. Very pretty, when the light's on it."

"What light?"

He did not answer that one.

I had spent my Sunday candle every week since February looking at my side of that wall. There was no green vein. Not near the hole. Not anywhere in the north drift.

It was in March, with the thaw coming down the shaft in a steady cold stream so that the foot of the ladder stood in water to the ankle, that I first heard him somewhere he should not be.

I was sitting by Tom at bucket time. Tom was eating. I had my back against the wall of the main cavern, a good forty paces from the north drift, and the rock behind me was solid. I knew that rock. I had leaned on it a hundred mornings.

Behind my head, inside the stone, someone coughed. Small and dry.

I came off that wall like it was hot. Tom looked up with bread in his beard.

"What?"

"Did you hear that?"

"I don't hear anything, lad. I'm deaf." He went back to his bread.

I stood in the water and stared at that wall in the grey light, and it was only a wall. I told myself it was the drip. I told myself it was some man in the cavern. I went back to my drift and did not go to the cavern again that week except for bread, and I did not lean on anything.

That spring I began to hear him walk.

It was always late, always after the hatch was barred. Steps on the far side of the rock, in the east drift. Slow ones. An old man's steps, not dragging any chain. They would come from far off, from deep in the hill, and get nearer, and nearer. And they would stop. Every time, they stopped at the same place. Right at the hole. Right at my head, on the far side of no more than a yard of stone.

Then nothing. Then, after a while, very softly: "Your move."

On the eighteenth of May the hatch was raised to let a prisoner's wife come down to her husband. I was in my drift. I heard the shout go up through the cavern, a roar of men, and the ladder shaking, and something hit the rock and screamed, and men were climbing and fighting at the top. Somebody fired. It went on a long time. I sat on my plank with my irons on and did not move. Tom told me after that a guard was killed up there, and others hurt, and about twenty got clear into the woods. Most of them were back inside a week, dragged down that ladder in heavier irons than before.

I did not go. I had my trade waiting in Hartford, and my name, and my dog. I was not going to come home a runaway.

Kirk was the one who could not leave that alone.

He came down two days after, in daylight, with the lantern full open for once, and stood over me.

"You didn't go."

"No."

"Every man in that cavern that could walk went up that ladder. You sat here." He tilted his head. "Why's that, printer?"

I said I meant to be let out, not to run.

"Let out," he said, as though tasting it. "And then what? Back to your press?"

"Yes."

He nodded slowly. The next morning there was salt beef in my bucket. A good piece, a pound at least. There was beef again the next week. Nobody else in the cavern had any. Tom asked me where I'd had it from, and I could not say, and I could not eat it either. I gave it to him. I lay awake with Bell's words a foot under my back. E. K. sells it on the Hartford road.

Kirk was everywhere after that. Mornings at the rope, watching me take my bread. Afternoons, standing at the mouth of the cavern, not doing anything. Nights, the thin blade of light across my floor. I never knew how long he had been there before I woke. The Neighbor did not speak at all for nine nights running.

In August a note came in the bread. Ruth Pike's round hand.

Your dog went off two days back. I have looked down to the river.

I sat with that paper in the grey at the shaft foot until the guard shouted at me to step away. That night I did not play. I lay facing the hole and said Tray's name into it, as if the Neighbor could carry it anywhere.

"Give it a day," he said quietly. It was the only time he ever told me anything that was not chess.

On the third day, another note.

He is back. Came in at dark with a rope on his neck chewed through. Somebody tied him in a shed. I do not know who. I am keeping him in the kitchen nights now.

He had chewed through it. The same as he chewed through the rope in the yard behind the shop, the day he followed me up Copper Hill.

The winter went by, and the next spring came, and I knew it by the water on the ladder. Bread began to come late. Some days not until afternoon. I heard the guards argue at the top of the shaft, loud, about wages, about who was to stand which watch, about some news from Hartford. One morning a guard on the rope said to another, careless, that the King's ministry in London was fallen, and the new men wanted peace, and the Tories down here would be let out by commission.

Down the hole that night, the Neighbor said, "That's a lot of talk at the top of a shaft."

"They say there'll be a list. Names. Men to be let out."

"Yes," he said. "That's when a careful man is most careful."

Above us, faint through all that rock, I heard the bar slide back on the hatch. Long after sundown. And then nothing at all came down.

I sat up. I held my breath and listened.

Earlier that day the bread had come down at nearly three in the afternoon, and with it, shouted from the top of the shaft to Tom by a guard in a good mood, the news that a lawyer had come up from Hartford with the Governor's papers. Mister Ashby, the guard said. A Council man. He was up there now in the guardhouse with the captain and a ledger as thick as your arm, and come morning there would be a list of names called down that shaft.

Tom had grinned at me with his four teeth. I had not let myself grin back.

Now the bar was off the hatch, and it was full dark, and I heard a new sound. The ladder. Coming down. Not dropped. Let down slow, rung by rung, hand under hand, the way you lower something you do not want to wake. Wood knocked once on the shaft wall. Then the foot of it touched the water at the bottom with a sound like a spoon set in a basin.

A yellow light hung far up at the top. Small. Steady.

"Thorne."

Soft. So soft it might have been the drip.

"Silas Thorne. Wake up, now."

I did not answer.

"It's Kirk. Your name's on the list." A pause. "Captain says you're to come up tonight. Quiet. Before the Tories. No sense a peace man going out with that lot in the morning, is there? Come on up."

I put my hand flat on the wall beside the hole. The stone was wet and cold.

"Don't," said the Neighbor, very low, just at my fingers. "Don't move. Don't speak."

"He says my name's on it."

"Then it'll still be on it at sunrise."

Kirk's voice came again, patient, almost fond. "Come up and breathe, printer. It's a warm night. There's blossom on the trees down the Hartford road. You can smell it from here."

I could not smell anything but stone. But I knew what he meant. I had not breathed open air in seventeen months. My whole body leaned toward that little yellow light like a plant on a sill.

Then something touched my ankle in the dark and I nearly cried out.

"It's Tom." His hand on my leg. His breath at my ear, sour, shaking. He had come up the drift on his knees so his chain would not ring. "I felt the ladder hit. I sleep against it. I feel it every time." He gripped my shin. "Don't you go."

"I'm not going."

"Listen. I never told you all of it. I found him. The schoolmaster." His mouth was right against my ear. "His irons were on him. Locked. You ever know a man to run without breaking his irons off first? Every man in May, first thing, they smashed their irons. And the candle. He had a candle end in his coat. That shaft runs like a gutter, lad, you've felt it. A man climbs it, he's soaked to the skin, pockets and all." His fingers dug in. "That candle was dry. Dry as Sunday. And he never called out. Not once. I'd have heard."

I sat there in the dark and saw it the way you see a page come up off the type, every letter at once. Bell had never climbed that ladder. Not up. Only down. All the way, and fast.

"Thorne." Kirk again. "I haven't got all night."

"No," said the Neighbor quietly. "He hasn't."

I put my mouth to the hole. "Tell me what to do."

There was a small dry cough. When he spoke it was the same voice he used across the board, mild, unhurried, a man looking at an endgame he has seen a thousand times.

"He has one move. The ladder. Everything he does tonight is that ladder. He wants you on it. You have no move at all, and that's your strength. Don't make one. Sit still. Make him come to you."

"And if he does come?"

"Then he comes down into the dark with a light in his hand, onto a board you know and he doesn't. But he won't want to. Coming down isn't the plan. Coming down leaves marks." A pause. "Who has the clock, printer?"

I thought about it. "He does. When it's light, Trask comes down with the list."

"With a lawyer at his elbow. So he has until sunrise, and he knows it. Every hour you sit there, his position is worse. Let him earn it."

Tom had heard none of that. He only heard me whispering into the wall. He let go of my leg and moved a little away from me in the dark, and I heard him mutter something like a prayer.

Kirk talked for a long time.

He told me the captain was waiting with my papers. He told me Ruth Pike had a hot supper on for me in the guardhouse kitchen. He told me he'd have the irons off at the top, he had the key on him, I'd only to climb. He was never loud. Never angry. Every so often he would go quiet for so long that I'd begin to think he had gone, and then the light would shift up there and his voice would come down again, kind as a mother.

"Your dog's up here, Silas. Mistress Pike sent him out. He wants walking home."

My heart turned over.

"Listen," the Neighbor said.

I listened. Water. My own blood. Tom's breathing.

No bark.

Tray barked at that hatch every morning of my first winter. He barked at anything. If he had been at the top of that shaft, with my name being called, he would have been screaming.

"He's lying," I whispered.

"Yes."

After that, Kirk stopped talking for a while. Then something small came down the shaft. It struck the ladder halfway, clicked off the rock, and landed in the water at the bottom with a little splash. Another. Another. One at a time, slowly, the way he had picked them off my board.

My chessmen. He was dropping my chessmen.

"Come and get your pieces, printer," he said softly. "You'll want them for the road."

I counted every one. Click on the wall. Splash. Thirty. Thirty-one. Then nothing. The thirty-second did not come. I sat in the dark and did not know which one he had kept back, and that was worse than all the rest.

Somewhere past what I took for midnight, in the east drift, I heard the footsteps start.

Far off, deep in the hill. Slow. No chain. Nearer. Nearer. I felt Tom go stiff beside me; I think he felt it in the floor. The steps came right up to the far side of the rock, to the hole, to my head, and stopped. And stayed. There was somebody standing on the other side of a yard of stone with me, all the rest of that night, and I swear I could feel him there the way you feel a man looking over your shoulder at your cards.

"Still here," the Neighbor murmured. "Still with you."

Toward the end of the night the light at the top of the shaft went out.

Then the ladder creaked. Not swaying. Taking weight. A heavy man's weight, setting his boot on the top rung, and then the next, and the next, coming down through the water in the dark.

"Neighbor," I breathed.

The hole said nothing. Only the drip.

He came down slowly. I counted the rungs by the creak, the way I had counted Tray's barks. Water hissed off him as he passed through the worst of the stream. His boots went into the pool at the bottom, and something small skittered away under them, one of my pieces, knocked against the stone.

Then a click. A shutter opening a crack. A blade of yellow fell across the cavern floor and lay there, and in it I saw the edge of a wet boot.

Beside me Tom had gone as still as a dead man.

"Thorne." Kirk spoke from the foot of the ladder. Not soft anymore. Only tired. "You've made this a deal harder than it needed to be."

I put my mouth to the hole without meaning to. I did not say anything. I only wanted to hear him. There was nothing. Not a cough. Not a breath. The man who had stood on the far side of that stone all night had gone wherever he went when Kirk came down, and there was nobody to tell me my move.

The blade of light turned toward the north drift and began to come.

I gathered my chain up off the floor into both fists so it could not ring. Tom had taught me that, crawling up to me in the night. I got my feet under me on the plank. I knew that drift. Seventeen months I had walked it blind. Four rough steps down from the platform to the bend. A lip on the third one that would catch a stranger's toe. The slop bucket against the left wall. A knob of rock at head height just past the bend that had split my scalp twice in my first week, and never again.

The light came round the bend. It touched the slop bucket. It touched Tom's bare foot.

Tom could not hear well. He could see. He saw the light on his own foot, and I think something in him simply would not sit still for it.

"Who's that?" he said. Loud. The way deaf men are loud. "Who's down here?"

The blade jerked toward him. Kirk came on fast. I saw his arm, his big hand, the lantern swinging, and then Tom was up off the floor and had both hands on that arm, an old man hanging onto it like a dog on a rope.

The lantern hit the rock. Glass went. The light went.

Dark.

I heard them in it. A scuffle. Boots slipping on the wet. Tom's breath coming out of him in a grunt. Then a sound I have heard since in my sleep more often than I can count, a heavy sound, short, like a sack of grain set down hard on a stone floor.

Then only Kirk breathing.

I did not call Tom's name. I wanted to. I stood in the black with my chain balled in my fists and my teeth clenched and did not call it, because the Neighbor had told me, make him come to you, and I knew that the first sound I made would be my position.

Kirk stood still a long time. Then he spoke, quite gently.

"I know you're there, printer."

I heard him take a step. His boot found the lip of the third step and caught on it, and he swore under his breath and caught himself on the wall. He did not know the drift. I did.

I moved. Along the right wall, one foot set down at a time, heel first, the way I would ease a full forme onto the bed of a press. Past where his breathing was. The roof came down low there and I bent under it without thinking, and a breath later I heard Kirk strike his head on that same knob of rock and grunt.

He turned toward my side. I stopped.

His hand came out in the dark. I felt the air move. His fingers brushed my sleeve, slid on the wet wool, closed on nothing. I did not move. I did not breathe. I stood with his hand a finger's width from my arm, and in my head, as plain as if he had said it through the stone, I heard the Neighbor's dry voice. Why resign? Let him earn his victory.

Kirk's hand went away. He took a step past me, deeper into the drift, toward the platform. Toward the place I had been.

I went the other way.

Down the last step. Past the bucket, one hand on the cold rim to know where it was. Out of the north drift into the open dark of the cavern, where thirty-odd men slept, and across it, counting my steps, to the foot of the shaft. My feet went into the water. Something rolled under my heel. A chessman. The ladder was there in front of me, wet, a long black frame going up into a darker black, and at the very top a faint grey square. The hatch, open. The first of the morning.

I could have climbed it. I want that understood. I had my hands on the rungs.

Don't take it at night. Not for any reason.

I let go of the ladder. I tipped my head back to that grey square, and I took the biggest breath I had taken in seventeen months, and I shouted.

"Captain Trask! Murder! There's murder in the mine!"

It went up that shaft like a shot out of a gun. And then, because I could not stop myself, because I had promised him, I shouted the only other word I had.

"Tray!"

Behind me in the dark, Kirk turned and came.

Men woke all over the cavern. Somebody yelled. Chains rang on stone. Kirk's boots were coming across the floor toward the shaft, fast, careless now, knocking into sleeping men, and I backed off along the wall to the right, away from the ladder, away from my own voice.

Then, far up at the top of the shaft, faint and high and cracked, a dog began to bark.

He did not stop. He did not stop at three or four the way he used to. He barked and barked, wild, without breath, and I heard a woman's voice up there shouting at him and then shouting at someone else, and a door bang, and men's voices.

Kirk was at the ladder. I heard the rungs take his weight. He was going up. A guard climbing out of the pit with the ladder down and the hatch open, in the dark, with a dead man behind him.

He was nearly halfway when the lights came.

Two lanterns, three, at the top of the shaft, held out over the edge. They lit the whole length of the ladder and the water streaming down it, and Enoch Kirk hanging there in the middle of it with his hat gone and blood in his hair from the knob of rock in my drift.

"Mister Kirk," said Captain Trask's voice from the top. Very quiet. "What are you doing on that ladder?"

And behind Trask, a thinner, sharper voice I had never heard before. "Is that the night guard, Captain?"

Kirk said a prisoner was escaping. He said he had come down after me. He said it well, very calm, still climbing.

"Stay where you are," Trask said. "Stay exactly where you are."

They brought him down. They came down behind him, Trask and two guards and the Hartford lawyer, Ashby, a narrow man in a good black coat with his ledger under his arm, of all things, as though he could not bear to set it down. The lanterns filled the cavern. Men stood blinking against the walls in their irons.

I was in my irons. I was soaked to the skin from standing in the shaft. Nobody needed to ask whether I had been escaping.

They found Tom in the north drift by the broken lantern. I will not describe him. He was an old man and the rock was very hard, and that was all there was to it.

Trask knelt by him a long time. When he stood his face had gone grey.

"Under the plank, sir," I said. My voice was hardly there. "Under the platform. The schoolmaster left it. He meant you to have it."

Trask held his lantern under the boards and looked up, the way I had. He did not speak. Ashby got down beside him in his good black coat in the wet and looked too, and then opened his ledger on his knee and ran a finger down a column.

"One pound of beef a man a week," Ashby said. "Paid out. Every quarter." He looked up the passage toward Kirk. "Paid to whom, I wonder."

At the top of the shaft somebody called down. A woman. Ruth Pike, holding Tray by the scruff, I learned later, to keep him from going down the ladder head first.

"Captain! The beef he sold me before Thanksgiving came in a cask with the Assembly's mark burnt on the lid. I asked him about it. He said he'd had it cheap."

Trask turned and looked at his night guard for what I believe was the first time in years.

They put Enoch Kirk in irons at the foot of his own ladder. Trask did it himself, by the book, and wrote it down in his own hand in the little register, while Ashby watched and nodded. When they turned out Kirk's pockets, the last of my chessmen was there. A chip of green ore, notched with a cross. My king.

They took him up at sunrise.

An hour after, with the light full grey in the shaft, Captain Trask stood at the foot of the ladder with Ashby's list and called names down into the cavern one by one. Tories, most of them.

And then, without looking up from the paper, "Silas Thorne."

They struck my irons off at the top. I stood in the yard with my face up and the rain on it, and Tray hit me hard enough to knock me into the mud. Ruth Pike stood over us with her arms folded and her eyes wet and told me he was too thin and so was I. It was there, with the dog's head under my hand, that I asked Trask about the east drift.

"There's a man in the east drift, sir. He kept me sane. I'd like to thank him before I go."

Trask looked at me the way he had looked at my bare chessboard once. Then he opened the register against his chest and turned back, page after page, to the very first leaf.

"The east drift was walled before this was a prison," he said. "After a roof fall. Nobody has been kept in it. Not one night." He showed me the column. Empty, in his own hand.

I asked him to look anyway. I do not know why he agreed. Perhaps because of Tom. So I went back down that ladder, in the daylight, of my own free will.

A guard pried a loose stone from the old wall at the end of the cavern, and I held a lantern to the gap.

Dust. Grey and smooth on the floor, without a single mark in it. At the far end, a slope of fallen rock to the roof, grey with the same dust. A bare rock ledge against the far wall, about the length of a man. And above the ledge, running from the floor across the roof and down again to a small round hole in the stone, a green vein of copper about two fingers wide.

Very pretty, when the light was on it.

I gave the lantern back and climbed the ladder into the daylight, where Tray was waiting. I walked him home to Hartford that same week, every mile of the Simsbury road, slow, because neither of us could manage any other way. He lived nine more years and slept under my type cases for every one of them.

A King's government that had won every battle in the newspapers had lost the war. Let him earn his victory.

I went back to the press. I married. I bought this shop. I set Bibles and almanacs and horse bills and one or two things I am proud of. An ordinary life, and a long one.

I fished thirty-one chessmen out of that water before I left, and Kirk's pocket gave me the thirty-second. They stand now on a little board in my back room, set as the last game stood, with my queen's rook brought across and his pawn answering it. It is his move. It has been his move for forty years.

Some mornings, not many, I find his spar pawn lifted and set down again on its own square, a hair crooked, as a man touches a piece while he thinks. My journeyman swears he never touches the board.

I'm seventy now, and I have never once finished that game. But I don't intend to resign. Let him earn his victory.