I Watch the Water at a Smoky Mountains Dam. A Lamp Burns Under the Lake.
I run the night drawdown patrol on Fontana Lake for TVA. This winter they took the water lower than anyone at the dam could remember, and on a stone foundation that's been underwater since 1944, someone had hung a burning lantern where the porch used to be.
This story is fiction, set against real places and real history.
Prefer to read it? Download the bedtime PDF (free to share, never to sell).
The real history behind the story
12 facts, each with its source
Fontana Dam and the Road to Nowhere (Lakeview Drive), Swain County, North Carolina
- Construction of Fontana Dam began on January 1, 1942, weeks after Pearl Harbor; water impoundment began November 7, 1944, about 35 months later, and electricity was first generated January 20, 1945.
Source: dncr.nc.gov - The dam's wartime power served the aluminum plants at Alcoa, Tennessee, and a top-secret weapons laboratory at Oak Ridge; displaced families were told only that it would power the Alcoa plant.
Source: tva.com - At 480 feet, Fontana is described by TVA as the tallest dam east of the Rockies.
Source: dncr.nc.gov - The Appalachian Trail crosses Fontana Dam (per tourism sources).
Source: explorebrysoncity.com - The project displaced some 1,311 families, required moving 1,047 graves, and flooded more than 60 miles of roads, including the existing Highway 288.
Source: en.wikipedia.org - Communities including Almond, Bushnell, Forney, Japan, Judson, Tuskeegee, Wayside and Welch were drowned under 10,600-acre Fontana Lake; Proctor was isolated by the lake and abandoned rather than flooded.
Source: dncr.nc.gov - On July 30, 1943, TVA, the Interior Department, North Carolina and Swain County agreed that TVA would buy 44,000 acres for the national park, the Park Service would build a road along the north shore to reach ancestral lands and cemeteries, and TVA would pay Swain County $400,000 for the flooded Highway 288.
Source: govexec.com - Work on the road, officially Lakeview Drive, stopped after about six miles, just after a 1,200-foot tunnel was built.
Source: en.wikipedia.org - A $52 million cash settlement was approved by Swain County commissioners 4-1 on February 5, 2010; $12.8 million was paid in 2010, payments stopped until 2017, and the final installment was paid in June 2018 to the state treasurer, with the county drawing the interest.
Source: appvoices.org - The Park Service ferries Swain County residents across Fontana Lake to visit family cemeteries for Decoration Days and reunions, with boats leaving every other Sunday from April to October.
Source: greatsmokies.com - TVA tore down and burned houses, barns and outbuildings to keep people from returning, while the construction camp became the second-largest city in western North Carolina, with more than 5,000 workers.
Source: ourstate.com - Where Lakeview Drive enters the park, a sign reads "Welcome to the Road to No-Where. A Broken Promise! 1943 – ?"
Source: 828newsnow.com
The legends
3 told as legend, not fact
These are told locally or were reported long ago but could not be confirmed. The story uses them as legend, not fact.
- The 1943 agreement is reported to have said that Congress's failure to appropriate funds would not breach the agreement, and this is said to be why lawsuits to force the road failed (from gribblenation.org, not independently checked).
- A local history site says the 1943 promise ended with lingering consternation and a road never completed.
- Families are said to have learned only after the war that the valley's power had helped feed the secret work at Oak Ridge.
Transcript
Read the full story
The last gauge on my list that evening was the staff gauge, a tall painted ruler bolted to the rock, off Lemmons Branch, and by the time I idled up to it the sun was already gone behind the ridge. That was January, and in January on Fontana Lake the light quits early and the cold comes up off the water like it has somewhere to be.
I put the bow against the rocks, held the boat there with one hand, and put my flashlight on the gauge. I wrote the number in the logbook on my knee. Then I looked at it a while, because I had been writing those numbers down for fifteen years and I had never written one that low.
At TVA we don't talk about how deep the lake is. We talk about elevation, feet above sea level. In early June, Fontana sits a little over seventeen hundred feet, full and green and pretty, and the tourists come down off the Appalachian Trail where it crosses the top of the dam and take pictures. Every fall we let it down to make room for the winter rains and the spring floods. Most years that drops her fifty-some feet and bares a good bit of old two eighty-eight and the Lands Creek bridge. That winter they'd taken it down further than anybody at the plant could remember, for work on the dam. The old-timers in the break room said they'd never seen the bottom look like that. I was thirty-nine, born and raised in Swain County, and I'd never seen it either.
What a drawdown shows you is the old valley. Roadbeds. Rock walls. A chimney fall here and there. Before the water came up in nineteen forty-four, there were towns down there. Every kid in Swain County grows up knowing that the way you know your own phone number.
I had the radio on my hip and my phone in my coat. It buzzed once. Marla, from the hospital in Bryson City.
Getting off at seven. Josie wants pancakes for supper. Don't argue.
I typed back that I never argued, which she knew wasn't true, and I put the phone away and pushed off.
The run home took me back down the Tuckasegee arm. Folks around here just call it the Tuck. The water was flat and dark and the banks rose up on both sides, bare gray mud with the old high-water line drawn along the top like a ring in a bathtub. I kept her slow. With the lake that low, there were stumps and rock where there had been forty feet of water in August, and I knew most of them but not all.
I was passing the mouth of a little dead-end cove on the north side when I saw it.
One small yellow light. Way up at the head of the cove, low, almost down on the mud.
I throttled back and let the boat drift.
That cove didn't go anywhere. The old Highway two eighty-eight runs down into the water there, and past that there's nothing but steep woods and Park Service land. No camp. No road. No dock. The old-timers called it Garland Cove. I'd heard that name my whole life and never once thought about it.
The light didn't move. It wasn't white like a headlamp or blue like a phone. It was yellow and soft, and it sat at about the height of a man's chest, maybe a little higher.
Pot hunters, I figured. People do come out on the bare lakebed at night to dig, with probe rods and metal detectors, looking for old bottles and buttons and whatever else they can sell. It's a federal crime. Part of my job that winter was to watch for them.
So I turned the wheel and brought the bow around toward the cove.
The light went out.
Not dimmed. Not swung away, like somebody turning to run. It was there, and then it wasn't, the second my bow came around to point at it.
I sat there with the motor ticking over and my spotlight in my hand, not switched on. The cove was black. The mud was black. I could hear the water against the hull and nothing else.
I didn't go in. It was getting dark, I was alone, and a man who walks out on drawdown mud at night without a probe pole can go in to his knees and stay there. I told myself somebody had heard my motor and cut their lantern. That made sense. I made a note of the time and the cove in the logbook, and I went home to pancakes.
That night, before bed, I turned off the porch light. I always do. I did it then out of habit.
I still do it every night. Only now I go back and check it twice.
I started night site-watch the next evening. During a drawdown like that one, TVA puts a man on the water after dark to keep an eye on the exposed lakebed, and that winter the man was me. It's one boat, one spotlight, and a radio. If I saw diggers, I called TVA Police. The officer who covered our lake covered three others besides, and on a good night he was an hour out. So mostly the job was riding slow and looking at mud.
I didn't mind it. I liked the lake at night. I knew every old roadbed and rock wall in it from the drawdown surveys, and I could find most of them in the dark by the shape of the ridges against the sky.
That Sunday we drove over to Bryson City for supper with my great-uncle Dewey, like we did most Sundays. Dewey was eighty-eight. He'd put in thirty-eight years at Fontana Dam before he retired, and when I was twenty-four and loading trucks at the lumber yard, he was the one who sat me down at his kitchen table, made me fill out the TVA application, and called every man he knew at the plant to put in a word. He never asked me for one thing back. I'd always meant to square that someday. I just figured someday was a long way off.
He lived alone in a little white house out Lakeview Drive, just past the sign. Everybody in Swain County calls it the Road to Nowhere. When they built the dam, they flooded the old Highway two eighty-eight and the towns along it, and the government promised a new road along the north shore so families could get back to their land and their graveyards. They built about six miles of it, and a tunnel, and quit. There's a sign out there that folks put up. It says, "Welcome to the Road to No-Where. A Broken Promise!" Then it's got the year nineteen forty-three, a dash, and a question mark where the end should be.
Josie read it out loud from the back seat as we passed, same as every week. She was eight and liked anything with a question mark on it.
Dewey had the cornbread done when we came in. He got around on a cane, but he got around. Marla went to help him with the beans, and he waved her off and let her help anyway.
At the table, Josie told him all about her science fair volcano. Dewey asked her good questions about it. Then he turned to me.
"How low you got her now?"
I told him the number off the Lemmons Branch gauge. He let out a long breath through his nose.
"I never saw it that low," he said. "Not once in thirty-eight years."
"Me neither. It's showing everything. Rock walls I never knew were there."
He nodded slowly. He'd been seven when his family left the valley in nineteen forty-four. I knew that much. I knew his people came from somewhere under the lake, same as half the old families in the county. He didn't talk about it much except on Decoration Day. That's the Sunday the old families clean and flower the graves, and the Park Service runs a boat across so they can get to them.
"Saw something funny the other night," I said. "Up a little cove off the Tuck. One of them dead-end ones on the north side. Garland Cove, the old boys call it."
Dewey's fork stopped.
"There was a light up there, low on the mud. I figured pot hunters. Went out soon as I turned toward it."
I'd meant it as nothing. Just work talk. But the color went out of Dewey's face all at once, like somebody had pulled a plug. His lips went thin and gray. He set his fork down very carefully beside his plate.
"What kind of light," he said.
"Yellow. Lantern, I guess."
"How high off the ground?"
It was a strange thing to ask. I held my hand up about level with my chest. "Bout like that."
Dewey looked at my hand for a long time. Nobody said anything. Josie looked from him to me.
Then he reached across the table and took hold of my wrist. His hand was cold and stronger than I expected.
"Don't you run that cove after dark," he said. "You hear me, Wade? Not after dark."
"Dewey, it's my job to—"
"I don't care what your job is." His voice didn't get louder. It got quieter. "Not that cove. Not after dark."
He held on until I said all right. Then he let go, picked up his fork, and asked Josie what color she'd painted the volcano.
He didn't say another word about it all evening.
When we left, I looked back from the truck. Every light in Dewey's house was on except one. The porch light was off, and he was standing behind the screen door in the dark, watching us go.
Monday I slept till noon, which is what night site-watch does to you. Marla had left for an early shift and stuck a note on the coffee maker. Josie's volcano was on the kitchen table under a dish towel, drying, and there was green paint on the cabinet door that I wiped off before anybody could be in trouble for it. I ate a sandwich standing up. I looked out the back window at the lake below the house, at the Almond boat ramp running way down past the end of its concrete into bare red mud. It looked like somebody had pulled a stopper.
By six I was on the water.
I ran my usual loop. Out from the dam, up the Tuck, slow along the north shore with the spotlight off, because you don't catch diggers by shining a light at them. You catch them by seeing theirs.
I'd promised Dewey. I want to be honest about that. I had every intention of staying out of that cove.
Then I came past the mouth of it at a little after ten, and the light was there.
Same as before. One soft yellow point, way up at the head, at about the height of a man's chest. It didn't move. It didn't flicker. It sat there like it was waiting on somebody.
I idled down. I thought about Dewey's cold hand on my wrist. And then I thought about some fella from Knoxville up there with a probe rod and a metal detector, digging through what was left of somebody's home and selling it online. Digging on TVA lakebed is a federal crime. Watching for it was the whole reason I was out there. Dewey was eighty-eight and had lost his home under that lake, and a light on the mud had stirred something up in him. That was all. That's what I told myself.
I turned in.
This time it didn't go out.
The cove was narrow, maybe a hundred yards across, with the banks going straight up into the dark woods on both sides. I kept the motor barely ticking. I could see the old Highway two eighty-eight roadbed on my right, a pale flat strip of packed gravel coming down off the ridge and running out into the mud. The water got shallow. My sounder, the depth finder, showed eight feet, then six, then four.
The light got bigger, and I started to see what was under it.
Before they filled the lake, TVA crews cleared the whole basin. They cut the timber and tore down or burned the houses and barns, so there wasn't much left to find in a drawdown but stone. Foundations, chimney bases, walls. And that's what was sitting up there on the bare mud, maybe thirty yards past the waterline. A low rectangle of fieldstone, gray and slick. A heap of fallen chimney rock at one end. And at the front, facing the old road, a set of stone steps. Four of them, going up to nothing.
I'd surveyed that cove in other drawdowns. That foundation had never come out of the water. Not once since nineteen forty-four, I'd bet my house on it.
The lantern was right beside the steps.
It was an old oil lantern, the kind with a glass chimney and a wire bail. It was burning steady. And it was hanging about six feet off the ground on nothing. No pole. No post. No tripod. It hung in the air beside the top step the way it would if a porch post were still standing there and somebody had hung it on a nail.
I cut the motor.
It got very quiet. The boat drifted and the hull touched mud and stopped. I could smell it then, coming across the water. Coal oil. Kerosene, my grandmama called it coal oil. And under that, wet woodsmoke, like a fire somebody had put out with a bucket.
I didn't see anybody. I kept looking for a man, for a shape crouched beside the foundation, for the glint of a detector. There wasn't anybody.
Then, from up by the steps, I heard a long thin creak. A rusty spring, stretching. And then a soft wooden slap.
I knew that sound. Every house I'd ever been in as a boy had a screen door that made it. The spring pulls, the door swings out, the spring pulls it back, and the frame hits.
There was no door. There was no house.
And something passed in front of the lantern.
It wasn't fast. It was about the speed of somebody walking along a porch. The flame went dark for a second, like a tall body had moved between it and me, and then it was bright again.
My hand found the spotlight. I didn't decide to. I just switched it on and swung it up the bank.
The beam hit gray stone, gray mud, four steps going up to nothing. And above them, empty air. The lantern was gone. Not lying on the ground. Not swinging. Gone.
I swept the light all over that foundation. I lit up both banks and the roadbed and the trees. My breath was loud in my own ears. Nothing moved anywhere.
I don't know how long I sat there. Long enough for my hands to get cold through my gloves. Then I switched off the spotlight, set an oar against the mud, pushed off, and started the motor. I turned the boat around and headed for the mouth of the cove.
I made it maybe fifty yards before I looked back over my shoulder.
It was lit again. Steady and yellow, behind me, at the height of a porch post.
I keyed the radio and called it in. I said, "Possible diggers in Garland Cove, north side of the Tuck. Somebody up there with a lantern."
My voice sounded normal. I was proud of that.
I did not say anything about the door.
I got home a little after three. The house sits on the hill above the Almond boat ramp, and you can see it from the road as you come around the last curve.
The porch light was on.
It wasn't the usual white of that bulb. It was softer than that. Yellower. I sat in the truck at the bottom of the driveway with the engine running and looked at it for a while before I went up.
Josie was standing at the front window in her nightgown with the curtain held back in one hand.
I came in quiet. Marla was asleep. I knelt down by Josie and she didn't look at me. She kept looking out at the porch.
"Why's the light on, Daddy? Nobody left it on."
"Mama probably forgot."
"No, she didn't. I watched her turn it off."
I went back out. The switch by the door was in the up position. I flipped it down and the porch went dark. Then, I'm not sure why, I reached up and laid my fingers on the bulb.
It was cold. Cold as the porch rail. Like it hadn't been burning at all.
I stood out there a minute in the dark. The lake was down below the hill, black and flat, and the bare mud of the ramp ran out into it. Nothing moved down there. I went inside and locked the door.
I carried Josie back to bed. She was eight and too big to carry, and I did it anyway. When I tucked her in, I said what I'd said every night since she was born. I don't know where I got it. It's just something I say when I've turned the last light off and everybody's under my roof.
"Light's out. Everybody's home."
She grabbed my sleeve. "Even when you're on the boat?"
"Even then."
"Promise you'll say it. Every night. Even if you have to call."
I promised. I meant it more than I'd meant anything in a while. I stood in her doorway after she fell asleep and looked at her, and at Marla through our bedroom door, and I counted them. Two. Everybody home.
The next afternoon my phone rang. It was Sergeant Nate Booker, TVA Police. Nate was in his mid-forties, steady and careful, and he'd been working drawdown sites on four lakes since before Christmas. He'd taken a boat up Garland Cove at noon.
"You were right," he said. "Somebody's been working that foundation. I got fresh probe holes all along the back wall. Bootprints in the mud, coming and going off the roadbed."
"What kind of prints?"
"Boots. Big ones. Muddy." He laughed a little. "They had a lantern, they heard your motor, they killed it. Probably laid flat behind that wall till you left. These guys use those battery camp lanterns now. Look just like the old ones."
I thought about a camp lantern hanging six feet up in the empty air. I thought about the door.
"Yeah," I said. "That makes sense."
And I want to tell you that I didn't believe him. But I did. I believed him because I wanted to, and it felt good, like setting down something heavy.
I worked Tuesday night like any other night. That was the whole point of believing Nate. If it was pot hunters, then it was my job, and I knew how to do my job.
At eight-thirty I idled in the lee of a point up the lake from the dam and called home. Marla put Josie on.
"Did you say it yet?"
"Saying it now. Light's out. Everybody's home."
"You're not home."
"I'm home in spirit. Go to sleep."
She giggled and hung up. I sat there a second with the phone warm in my hand, and then I started up the Tuck.
I didn't plan to go into the cove. I planned to sit off the mouth with my lights out and wait for diggers to show themselves, and then call Nate. That's what I did. I tucked the boat in against the far bank across from the opening, killed the motor, and watched.
The lantern came on at about eleven.
I didn't see it light. One second the head of the cove was black, and the next it was there, steady and yellow at porch-post height, like it had always been there and I had just now looked at it right.
The smell came maybe a half a minute later. Coal oil and wet woodsmoke, all the way out at the mouth. A hundred and fifty yards, and it was as strong as if somebody had a lamp burning in the boat with me.
Then I saw the other light.
It was a flashlight, white and jumpy, coming down the old Highway two eighty-eight roadbed off the ridge on the right side of the cove. Somebody on foot. I could see the beam bouncing with every step.
Here's your digger, I thought. I picked up the radio. Then I put it down and picked up the spotlight instead, because the flashlight wasn't going toward the foundation. It was going down the roadbed, and the roadbed doesn't stop at the foundation. It goes right on past it, down the mud and into the water.
I hit him with the spotlight.
He was a big man in a camouflage jacket with a probe rod in one hand and the flashlight in the other. He had a backpack on. He didn't flinch from my light. He didn't even turn his head. He was looking up and to his left, at the lantern, and he was walking at a steady, easy pace, like a man walking up to a house he'd been invited to.
"TVA!" I yelled. "Stop right there!"
He kept walking.
I started the motor and gunned it straight across the cove toward the roadbed. "Hey! Stop! You're walking into the water!"
He passed the foundation. He passed the steps. The lantern hung there over his left shoulder, and he kept his face turned up to it the whole time, even as he walked away from it. The roadbed went from gravel to mud. He didn't slow down.
My sounder dropped to three feet, then two, and the hull hit the silt and stopped dead. I nearly went over the bow. I grabbed the probe pole. Every crew that works drawdown carries one, a long steel rod with a handle, because that mud is fine as flour and slick as grease and it'll take you to the knee before you know it. I jammed it down over the side, hit nothing solid, and went over anyway.
I went in to my thigh on the first step. The cold took my breath. On the second step I couldn't pull my leg back out.
He was in the water by then. To his knees. To his waist. The flashlight was still in his hand and the beam went under and lit the brown water from inside.
"Turn around!" I screamed it. "Turn around!"
He went under. He never put his arms out. He never kicked. The beam went down at a slant, getting dimmer and greener, and then it went out.
And up by the steps, in the dark, I heard the spring creak. Long and slow. And the soft slap of a door frame.
When I looked up, the lantern was out.
I got myself back in the boat somehow. I lost a boot doing it. I radioed it in shaking so hard I had to say the location three times.
Nate got there a little after one with the county rescue boat behind him. They dragged off the end of the roadbed in the dark and found nothing. At first light, Nate went down the roadbed on foot with a pole and found the bootprints. They came down off the ridge in a straight line. They went past the steps without a wobble. They went down the mud and off the end of the old highway and into the channel, where the creek used to run before the lake, and they didn't come back out.
They pulled the man up about nine in the morning. He was from Maryville. He'd been in trouble for digging before.
Nate stood on the roadbed for a long time afterward with his hands on his belt, looking at the foundation. He didn't say anything about camp lanterns. He didn't ask about the door. When he finally looked at me, he looked older than he had the day before.
"Stay off that cove," he said. That was all.
I drove to Bryson City that afternoon without calling first.
Dewey opened the door before I knocked. He looked at me, and at my face, and at my wet jeans that I hadn't changed, and he stepped back to let me in.
"You went up there," he said.
"Yes, sir."
"After dark."
"Yes, sir."
He sat down in his chair by the window and laid his cane across his knees. I told him all of it. The lantern, the door, the shape in front of the flame. The man walking into the water. Dewey listened with his eyes shut.
When I finished he didn't say anything for a long time.
"That was my granddaddy's house," he said at last. "Ezra Garland. I was seven when we left. TVA bought the land and gave us a deadline, and everybody went. Everybody but him. He wouldn't go. My daddy begged him. My mama cried. He stood out on that porch with a lamp in his hand, and when we pulled out on the old road, he hollered after us."
Dewey opened his eyes.
"He said, 'I'll keep the lamp lit till one of you comes back up these steps.'"
I didn't say anything.
"Clearing crew went in after. Said they burned the house. Said it was empty. But we all looked back from the road, Wade. All of us. And that lamp was burning on the porch post. Granddaddy was never found. Not then. Not ever."
"And nobody went back."
"How would we?" His voice went hard. "They flooded the road. They promised us a new one, and they built six miles of it and a tunnel and quit. The Park Service boat takes you to the graveyards. It don't take you up Garland Cove. And them steps have been under eighty feet of water since before you were born. Till now."
"Dewey. What is it?"
He looked straight at me.
"It's him, keeping his word. That lamp calls his own. Garland blood. It finds you wherever you lay your head, and it keeps on calling till one of us climbs them steps. Anybody else who goes to it, it don't want. They just keep walking. Off the road and into the water. Like that man did. It don't know there's a lake, Wade. It walks you the old road home, and the old road's under the water now. Only from the foot of them steps can you go up and not under."
"I'm not a Garland," I said. It came out thin.
"Your grandmama was Ruth Garland," Dewey said. "My sister. She was in the truck with me. She looked back too. First time, it didn't know you. You told me about it at my table. Then it knew."
I thought about the porch light. Yellower than the bulb. Cold to the touch. Josie at the window with the curtain in her hand.
Dewey was watching my face.
"It's been on at your house," he said. It wasn't a question.
"Once."
He nodded slowly and looked out his window at his own porch, at the dark bulb over his door.
"Mine's come on every night this week," he said. "I sit up with it. I'm too old to walk that far, and it knows it. That's why it went looking for younger legs."
Dewey wouldn't let me stay. I offered to sleep on his couch, and he told me no, go home to my girl. He said it twice. When I went down his steps to the truck, I heard him lock the door behind me, and then the porch light came on over my head.
He'd turned it on himself. I could see him through the window, his hand still on the switch, looking at the bulb. It burned plain and white. He left it that way.
I told Marla that night after Josie was asleep. All of it. The lantern, the door, the man from Maryville, Ezra Garland and his promise. We sat at the kitchen table with Josie's volcano between us under its dish towel, and Marla listened without stopping me once. She does that at work. She lets people get it all out.
When I was done, she reached over and put her hand on mine.
"Wade. Honey. When did you last sleep a whole night?"
"That's not what this is."
"I know it's not. I'm just asking." She squeezed my hand. "You watched a man drown. You tried to get to him and you couldn't. That's a terrible thing. That's going to sit on you."
"And the porch light?"
"This house was built in seventy-one. Half the outlets in the back bedroom don't work. You want me to believe a dead man turned on our porch light, or you want me to call an electrician?"
I didn't say anything.
"And Dewey," she said, more gently. "Wade, he's eighty-eight. He lost his home when he was seven years old, and it's been under that lake his whole life, and now all of a sudden there it is. I see it at the hospital all the time. The old folks, near the end. They go back. They talk to their mamas. They want to go home." She shook her head. "That doesn't make it true. It makes it sad."
I wanted to believe her. That's the thing I keep coming back to. Both times somebody handed me an easy answer that winter, I took it with both hands.
Nate called Thursday morning. He said the medical examiner had the Maryville man as accidental drowning. Blood alcohol came back zero. The rest of the tox would take weeks.
"So what walked him into the lake?"
"Hypothermia does strange things to a person. I've seen men take their coats off in the snow." He paused. "Fella had a record, Wade. He was out there at night stealing off federal land. He went down that roadbed in the dark and misjudged where the mud ended. That's what's in my report."
"You saw those prints. He didn't misjudge anything. He walked in like he was going up the front walk."
Nate was quiet on the line for a long time.
"That's what's in my report," he said again. "And I'm putting the cove off limits after dark. TVA Police, not just you. Nobody goes up there at night till the water comes back."
"Is that in your report too?"
"Stay off that cove," he said, and hung up.
So I decided to wait it out. It seemed like the sensible thing, and I'm a sensible man. The work on the dam was scheduled to wrap up in eleven days. Once it did, we'd start holding water back for the spring. Those four steps sat low on the cove floor. With any kind of winter rain, they'd be under in a day or two of filling, and they'd stay under, the way they had since nineteen forty-four.
Eleven days. I wrote it on the calendar on the refrigerator and circled it. Marla saw it and didn't ask.
I didn't go up the cove. I ran my night loop and I stayed off the north side of the Tuck altogether. I called home at eight-thirty and said it to Josie on the phone. The porch light stayed dark. For two nights, nothing happened, and I started to sleep a little.
Saturday afternoon I took the boat out to check the trash boom up the Tuck, the floating log line that catches drift before it gets to the dam. Daylight, a gray, cold sky, no breeze to speak of. Ordinary work.
I keep the sounder on whenever I'm moving, out of habit. It draws the bottom as a line under the boat, rising and falling. I know that bottom. I know where the old creek channels run and where the roadbeds cross them. With the basin cleared before the flooding, there's nothing much down there but silt and stone.
I glanced down at the screen and saw a roof.
A pitched roof. A sharp peak, with two straight slopes running off it at a steep angle, sitting up out of the flat silt line. At one end of it there was a short square stub standing up higher. A chimney.
I stared at it. I knew there was nothing on that bottom. I'd surveyed it. Then I looked up from the screen to see where I was.
I was in the cove.
I was halfway up Garland Cove, in broad daylight, running about ten miles an hour straight at the head. The foundation was right there in front of me on the gray mud, and the four steps facing me. I had no memory of turning in. None. I'd been on the Tuck, headed for the boom, and now I wasn't.
My right hand was on the throttle. It was pushing forward.
I told it to stop and it didn't, not right away. I watched my own fingers holding that throttle down like they belonged to somebody else. I had to take my left hand off the wheel and pry them loose one at a time. The motor dropped to an idle. The boat coasted. The steps kept coming toward me, slower and slower, and stopped maybe forty yards off.
I could smell coal oil.
It was the middle of the afternoon. There was no lantern. There was nothing but gray stone and gray mud and those steps going up to empty air. But the smell was there, plain as anything, and the screen in front of me still showed a house standing on the bottom where there was no house, with its roof peak right under my bow.
I threw it in reverse and backed all the way out of that cove without turning around. I didn't want to take my eyes off those steps.
At the mouth, the roof on the screen flattened out into a line of silt. Like it had never been there.
I sat out on the Tuck with my hands in my lap until they stopped shaking. Then I looked down at my right hand. There was a smell on my fingers. Coal oil. Dewey had said after dark. I guess once it knew my name, it didn't need the dark anymore.
I didn't tell Marla about the throttle. I scrubbed my hand at the shop sink with orange soap until the skin went pink, and I could still smell it on the drive home.
I had Saturday and Sunday nights off. I'd been looking forward to them all week.
Sunday morning I went out to get the paper and stopped on the top porch step.
There were bootprints coming up my steps.
They came up out of the yard. I could see them in the frost on the grass, a line of dark, flattened places running up from the bottom of the hill, from the direction of the lake and the boat ramp. Then they climbed the porch steps, one print to a step. They were wet. Not muddy. Wet, like a man had walked up out of the water, and the water had run down out of his clothes into his boots.
They were big. Bigger than mine. And they had a pattern I hadn't seen since I was a boy, in my granddaddy's barn. Rows of little round dots across the sole. Hobnails. Old work boots with iron nails driven through the bottom.
The prints went up the four steps and across the boards to the porch post by the door. Then they stopped. Two of them, side by side, facing the house. Like whoever made them had stood there a long time.
Next to them, on the porch post, at about the height of my chest, I smelled coal oil.
I got down and touched one of the prints. The water in it was so cold it stung.
I didn't wake Marla. She'd come off a late shift. I stood there trying to think of a way to tell her that didn't sound like an old man's story or a man who hadn't slept. By the time I went in for a towel, the sun had come over the ridge, and when I got back out, the prints were going. The frost was melting around them. In ten minutes they were just wet boards like the rest.
Josie came down for breakfast in her socks. She climbed up on her chair across from her volcano and looked at me over her cereal.
"Daddy, who's the man with the lamp?"
I set my coffee cup down.
"What man, baby?"
"The one that stood on the porch last night. He had a lamp like in the olden days." She took a bite. "He was all wet. He looked in the window at me."
"Were you dreaming?"
She thought about it. "I don't think so. He was nice. He held the lamp up so I could see him."
Marla had come in behind me in her robe. I turned around and she was looking at Josie, and then at me. She didn't say anything. She went and poured herself coffee with her back to us.
That night I locked both doors and checked them. Then I checked them again. I turned off the porch light and stood by the switch until I was sure. I went in and said it to Josie with my hand on her hair.
"Light's out. Everybody's home."
"The man says that too," she said sleepily.
I stayed awake until about one. I didn't mean to fall asleep. I was sitting up in bed with the lamp on and a book I wasn't reading.
What woke me was the storm door.
Our front door has a glass storm door on it with a pump closer. It doesn't creak. It hisses. But what I heard from the bed, in the dark, was a long rusty spring stretching out, and then the soft slap of a wooden frame.
I was on my feet before I knew it. Josie's door was open. Her bed was empty. The covers were thrown back, and her pillow was still warm when I put my hand on it.
The front door was standing wide open and the cold was pouring in. Both locks turned back.
The porch light was on.
It was yellow. Soft and yellow. And it lit up a set of small bare footprints going down the porch steps and out across the frost toward the lake.
I didn't get my shoes. I grabbed the flashlight off the hook by the door and ran.
Our yard drops off steep down to the road, and across the road is the Almond boat ramp. With the lake that low, the concrete runs out a long way and then there's red mud, and then the water. I came down the hill so fast I fell once and got up. I could see her from the road.
Josie was in the lake.
She was in her white nightgown, past the end of the concrete, in the water up to her knees. She was walking out. Slow and steady, with her arms at her sides. It was January. That water was cold enough to knock the breath out of a grown man and keep it.
And out past her, maybe fifty yards out over the open water, there was a light. Yellow. Hanging at the height of a porch post, over nothing at all.
I screamed her name. She didn't turn around.
I hit the mud running and went in to my shins. I pulled out and kept going. The water hit my feet and I lost my breath and kept going. She was in to her thighs now. I got her around the waist and lifted her clear, and she fought me. She kicked and twisted and reached out toward the light with both hands.
"Let me go! He's waiting!"
"Josie!"
"He said the lamp's lit for me!" She was crying. "He said I'm the one coming home!"
I turned toward shore with her in my arms.
And I didn't go.
I want to say this plainly. I was standing in that lake to my knees with my daughter against my chest, and I turned to go back to the ramp, and my feet didn't move that way. They wanted the other way. They wanted to go out toward that light. Nothing in me was afraid of the cold anymore. That light looked warm. It looked like the lamp in my grandmama's kitchen window when I was little, coming up the hill after dark. All I had to do was walk to it.
I took a step toward it. I felt the bottom drop away under my foot.
Josie screamed in my ear. A real scream, a little girl's scream, scared.
It went through me like cold water. I threw myself backward. I fell on my seat in the mud with her on top of me and crawled backward up the ramp on my elbows, dragging her, until I felt concrete.
When I looked up, the light was gone.
Marla was at the top of the ramp in her robe. I don't know how long she'd been standing there. She came down and took Josie from me without a word. Josie's nightgown was soaked through to the chest, where she'd gone under when I fell with her, and stuck to her, dripping lake water on the concrete.
Marla held her and looked at that wet nightgown in the glow from the streetlight. Then she looked out at the black water.
"Wade," she said. Very quietly. "Get her inside."
We got her inside and into a warm bath. Warm, not hot. Marla said hot can hurt a chilled child. She held her in it and kept two fingers on Josie's wrist the whole time, and she said if her lips weren't pink in twenty minutes, we were going to Swain. Josie's lips were blue when we started. She stopped shivering about half an hour later and fell asleep in a towel on Marla's lap, and she didn't remember any of it. Not the door. Not the lake. Not the man.
Marla didn't ask me one question that night. She just stayed up with me in the kitchen until daylight, with Josie asleep on the couch where we could see her.
Around five she said, "I want to take her to my sister's. In Asheville."
"Dewey said it finds you wherever you lay your head."
"Then we don't lay our heads." She said it like a nurse, flat and practical. "A week. You said a week and the water comes up."
"A week," I said.
It wasn't a week.
I went in to the plant Monday afternoon to tell them I couldn't run the boat that night. The revised schedule for the dam work was pinned up by the door. The crews had opened up the gate works and found more than anybody had planned on, and the job had been pushed back. The new date for refilling was the middle of March.
Six weeks. Six more weeks with those steps out of the water.
I stood there reading the paper twice. Then I drove home. By then Marla had thought it through. Her sister has two little ones. "I'm not carrying this into their house," she said. "We do it here."
That night we didn't put Josie in her room. We made a bed for her on the floor of our bedroom, between our bed and the wall, where nobody could get to the door without stepping over one of us. I checked both locks. I took the sleigh bells off the wreath we hadn't put away from Christmas and hung them on the front doorknob, so if it turned I'd hear it. I unscrewed the bulb from the porch light and put it in a kitchen drawer.
And I turned off every light in the house.
Marla asked me why. I told her the truth. With the lights on inside, the windows turn to mirrors, and you can't see out. I wanted to see it coming.
I set the alarm on my phone to go off every fifteen minutes, so I wouldn't drift off. And I said to Marla, "If I get up and you don't know why, you say my name. Loud. Don't touch me first. Just say it."
"Why?"
"Because that's what stopped me in the lake. Her voice."
She looked at me in the dark. She nodded.
I said it to Josie at nine o'clock, kneeling down on the floor with my hand on her hair. "Light's out. Everybody's home."
She was already asleep.
For two hours nothing happened. I sat up against the headboard. Marla sat in the chair by the window with a blanket around her. Every fifteen minutes the phone buzzed in my hand, and I looked at Josie, and I counted. One. Two. Three of us.
At a little after eleven, the window over Marla's chair went yellow.
Not bright. Just a faint glow on the glass, like light coming around the corner of the house from the front. Marla turned in her chair and looked. I watched her face go still.
"Wade," she whispered. "The porch."
The bulb was in a kitchen drawer.
A minute later I smelled it. Coal oil. It came under the bedroom door, faint and then not faint. Then woodsmoke, wet and sour.
Then I heard the boards on the porch.
Slow. Heavy. One step, a long wait, another. Back and forth in front of the door. The old boards there pop when you step on them, and they popped, one after the other. Something walked the length of our porch and stopped and turned and walked back.
Josie sat up.
Her eyes were open. She was looking at the bedroom door, and she wasn't seeing it. She pushed her blanket off and started to get up.
"Josie." Marla was out of the chair. "Baby, lie down."
Josie stood up anyway. Marla caught her around the middle and she didn't fight, she just kept walking, her bare feet pushing against the carpet, leaning toward the door like she was walking into a heavy breeze.
"He's got the lamp," Josie said. Her voice was calm and sleepy. "He's holding it up so I can see the steps."
Marla sat down on the floor and pulled Josie into her lap and wrapped both arms around her. Josie's feet kept moving, slow, like she was walking in a dream. After a while they stopped. Her eyes closed. She slumped against Marla, asleep.
The glow at the window got brighter.
It went on like that all night. I won't tell every bit of it. The steps on the porch would stop, and the glow would fade, and we'd breathe. Then twenty minutes later it would come back. The smell of coal oil got so strong my eyes watered. Three times, Josie sat up and tried to go. Three times, Marla held her until she went limp.
Some time after two, the glow moved.
It came around the side of the house. It slid along the bedroom wall from the front window to the side window, the one over our bed, and it stopped there. Through the curtain, I could see it. A round yellow light hanging at the height of a man's chest. Right outside. Right at the window a foot from my head.
Something passed in front of it. Something tall. The glow went dark for a second, then came back.
I didn't decide to get up. I want that understood.
I was standing in the hallway. I don't remember getting there. I was at the front door with my hand on the deadbolt, and the deadbolt was already turned back, and the sleigh bells were in my other hand, held tight against my palm so they wouldn't ring. I had muffled them myself. I had done that, without knowing it, so nobody would hear me go.
Through the glass of the storm door, the porch was gold. And warm. I could feel the warmth through the glass. My hand went to the knob.
"Wade!"
Marla's voice, from the bedroom. Loud.
It hit me like a slap. I let go of the knob. I stood there shaking, with the bells in my fist, and I turned the deadbolt back and stepped away from the door.
Through the glass I heard the rusty spring stretch out, slow, and the soft wooden slap of a screen door that wasn't there.
I sat down on the floor of the hallway with my back against the bedroom door and didn't get up again until the windows went gray.
The glow faded at about six. The smell hung on longer.
At six-twenty, my phone rang. It was Dewey.
"It came to your house," he said.
"Yes, sir. All night."
"The girl?"
"She's all right. She tried to go. Three times."
He was quiet for a long moment. When he talked again, his voice was steady, but it was slow, the way he talked when he'd been thinking about something for a long time.
"There's something I didn't tell you, Wade. When we pulled out on that road in forty-four, I was in the back of the truck. Ruth was crying against my shoulder. Mama and Daddy were up front. Granddaddy came to the top of the steps with the lamp, and he looked right at me. Right at me. And I hollered back at him. I hollered, 'I'll come back, Granddaddy.' And that's when he said it."
I closed my eyes.
"He said it to me," Dewey said. "I'm the one that promised. And I never went. Not in eighty years."
"Dewey."
"I'm eighty-eight years old, son. I've had my whole life. Josie hasn't had hardly any of hers." His voice cracked once and then came back. "I'm going up them steps. But I can't walk that mud by myself, and I can't run a boat in the dark no more."
I knew what he was going to say before he said it.
"You owe me nothing," Dewey said. "I want you to know I know that. But I'm asking you anyway. Take me up that cove tonight."
"Yes, sir," I said. "I'll take you."
I didn't tell Marla until I'd hung up. She was sitting on the bedroom floor with Josie still asleep across her lap. She listened, and she looked down at our girl, and she didn't argue. That's how I knew how scared she was.
"Come back," was all she said.
I slept a few hours that afternoon. Marla stayed awake. At six I drove to Bryson City.
Dewey was waiting on his porch in the cold. He had on his good gray suit and his long wool overcoat, and his shoes were polished. He had his cane in one hand. In the other he had a little paper sack. When he got in the truck he set it on his knees.
"What's that?"
"Lemon drops," he said. "Granddaddy liked them."
Dewey asked me to drive out past the sign first. I didn't ask why. The headlights crossed the sign. A Broken Promise. The year, the dash, the question mark. Dewey looked at it the whole way past.
"They never did build it," he said. "Reckon I'll go the old road."
I'd told nobody at the plant. I took the boat out of the TVA dock like it was any other night on site-watch, and I didn't key the radio once. Nate had closed that cove after dark. If he'd known, he'd have stopped me. I think he'd have been right to.
Dewey sat on the cooler in the middle of the boat with his coat pulled tight and his cane between his knees. He didn't say much on the way up the Tuck. It was clear and still and bitter cold, and the stars were thick over the ridges.
At the mouth of the cove, I slowed down.
"Dewey," I said. "Last chance."
"Go on."
So I went in.
The lamp wasn't lit yet. The cove was black. I kept the spotlight off and ran by the shape of the banks against the sky. My sounder dropped. Eight feet. Four. The flat pale strip of the old Highway two eighty-eight came down off the ridge on my right and ran into the water ahead of me. I eased the boat up onto the end of it until the hull scraped gravel, and I shut off the motor.
It was so quiet I could hear Dewey breathing.
I got out first, onto the roadbed. It held. The old road was packed hard under a skin of silt, and on either side of it the mud was soft as pudding. I'd brought the probe pole. I helped Dewey over the side. He was light. Lighter than I remembered. He took my left arm and kept his cane in his right hand, and I held the pole in my free hand and pushed it down ahead of every step to make sure the road was there.
We walked up the old highway toward the steps.
It was maybe thirty yards. It took us a long time. Dewey's breath smoked in front of him. My flashlight was in my coat and I left it there. I wanted to see what was coming.
About halfway up, the lamp came on.
It was right where it always was, at porch-post height beside the top step. Steady and yellow. Dewey stopped walking. His hand tightened on my arm.
"There he is," he said softly.
The smell came down the road to meet us. Coal oil. Woodsmoke. And something else, under it, that I hadn't smelled before. Supper. Cornbread and side meat, the salt pork my grandmama fried.
We kept walking.
I watched the lamp the whole way, and somewhere in those last few yards the dark around it changed. I don't know how else to say it. There was a shape behind the lamp that hadn't been there. Then there was a line under the lamp, straight and pale, that was a post. Then a roof line above it against the stars. Then boards.
When we got to the foot of the steps, the house was standing there.
It was all there. Gray clapboard siding, the paint long gone. A tin roof with a steep pitch and a stone chimney at the end. A porch across the front with a rail, and a post on the left, and the lamp hanging from a nail on that post. Four stone steps going up to the porch boards. Windows with no light in them. And a screen door, standing open.
There was a man in the doorway.
He was tall. Taller than me by a head, and so thin his overcoat hung off him like it was on a hook. The coat was soaked through. Water ran off the hem and off his sleeves and dripped on the porch boards with a soft, steady patter. Everything about him was the color of lake silt. His coat, his hands, his face. His hair was plastered flat to his skull. He had big old boots on, and I knew what the bottoms of them looked like.
He'd taken the lamp off the nail. He was holding it up high, in one long gray hand, so the light fell down the steps toward us.
I couldn't see his eyes. The light was below his face and the shadows sat in the hollows of it. But I knew he was looking at us. And I knew he was glad.
That's what I wasn't ready for. I'd been ready for something terrible. He wasn't terrible. He was waiting, the way somebody waits at a door at the end of a long day, and we'd finally come up the road.
And I wanted to go up.
It came over me all at once, warm and easy. I'd been cold for near two weeks. I'd been scared for near two weeks. Up there was a porch, and a lamp, and a kitchen with supper on, and an old man who'd waited eighty years and would never be disappointed in me. All I had to do was climb four steps. My foot was already on the first one. My hand was on the porch rail. The wood was wet and smooth under my glove.
"Wade."
Dewey's voice. Quiet.
I didn't look at him. I was looking at the lamp.
He took hold of my wrist. The same way he had at his supper table a week and a half before, his cold old fingers around my wrist, stronger than they had any right to be. And he lifted my hand off that rail.
"Don't you follow me up these steps," he said. "You hear? It only wants one of us. And it's gonna be me."
I couldn't answer. I could feel my other foot wanting to come up onto the step beside the first.
"Look at me, son."
I turned my head. It was hard. It was like turning against a current. But I did it, and I looked at him. At his white hair and his good gray suit and his polished shoes. He was smiling.
"You've got a girl at home," Dewey said, "waiting on you to say it."
And I thought of Josie. Asleep on the bedroom floor with Marla holding her. Her hand on my sleeve that first night. Even when you're on the boat. Promise you'll say it.
That warm house up those steps wasn't my home. My home was on a hill in Almond with the porch light off and two people inside it. Nobody was going to count them tonight if I went up there.
I took my foot off the step.
It was the hardest thing I've ever done in my life. I set it back down on the old road, on the silt and the gravel. Then I let go of Dewey's arm. Then I took one step backward.
Dewey squeezed my wrist once and let go. He put the paper sack in his coat pocket. He took his cane in his right hand and the porch rail in his left, and he went up.
He went slow, one step at a time, an old man on old stones. On the second step he stopped to get his breath. On the third, he set his cane against the rail and left it there. He didn't need it anymore. He went up the last step on his own.
The tall gray man lowered the lamp a little, so the light was on Dewey's face.
"I come back, Granddaddy," Dewey said. His voice was a boy's voice. "I'm sorry I took so long."
The man stepped back out of the doorway to let him in.
Dewey went past him into the house. The man stood a moment more on the porch with the lamp in his hand. I thought he looked down the steps at me. I'll never be sure.
Then he went in after Dewey.
The screen door spring stretched out, long and rusty.
The door swung to. The wooden frame slapped soft against the jamb.
And the lamp went out.
It was black. All at once and all the way. No house. No porch. No man. Just stars, and the cold, and the smell of coal oil fading off into nothing.
I pulled the flashlight out of my coat and turned it on with my hands shaking so bad the beam jumped all over.
Four stone steps on a bare fieldstone foundation, going up to empty air. The chimney rock in a heap. Gray mud.
Dewey's cane was lying across the third step.
"Dewey," I said.
Nothing.
"Dewey!"
My voice went up the cove and came back off the ridges. Nobody answered.
I didn't go up the steps. I wanted to. I want you to know I stood there and wanted to, for him this time. But I'd made my choice, and he'd made his.
I sat down on the old road at the foot of the steps, with the flashlight off and the probe pole across my knees, and I waited for it to get light.
The sky over the ridge started going gray a little before seven. I must have closed my eyes, because when I opened them I could see the mud, and the stones, and the steps.
Dewey was sitting on the bottom step.
He was sitting up straight with his hands in his lap and his chin down, like a man resting after a long walk. His good gray suit was soaked through. His overcoat was soaked. Water stood in the creases of it and dripped off his cuffs onto his polished shoes. His white hair was plastered flat.
The stone under him was dry. All four steps were dry. There was frost on the mud all around.
He was gone. I knew it before I touched his hand.
His coat pocket was empty. I never did find the lemon drops.
I keyed the radio then, for the first time all night. Nate came himself. He looked at Dewey, and at the dry steps, and at me, and he didn't ask what I was doing up that cove after dark. The medical examiner said it was his heart. Eighty-eight, out in the cold. Nobody argued.
Josie slept through that night. And the next, and every night after. The porch light stayed dark, and I put the bulb back in the first week of February. The dam work wrapped up in March, and the water came back, and by the end of April Garland Cove was under forty feet of green lake, steps and all.
That was two winters ago. I'm forty-one now, and I'm still at Fontana. I still read the gauges. I still know every roadbed under that lake.
I don't run that cove after dark. Not ever.
Last winter we had an ordinary drawdown. Nothing like the deep one. By every number I wrote in my logbook, those steps were twenty feet under. But one night in January, coming home down the Tuck, I looked up that cove and saw a light. One faint yellow point, way up at the head. Low. About the height of a porch post.
I didn't turn toward it. I watched it in my mirror till the ridge cut it off.
It wasn't there the next night. I checked.
So every night now, I go to the door and turn off the porch light. Then I go back and check it twice. I count them. Marla, asleep. Josie, ten years old now, asleep with her arm thrown over her face.
Then I put my hand on my daughter's hair, the way I promised her I always would.
"Light's out," I tell her. "Everybody's home."
