I Worked a Log Salvage Boat Off Vancouver Island. Something Followed Us Home.
Out past Cape Scott, where nobody checks what a salvage crew takes, our captain had me saw the roots off a living yellow cedar worth more than our whole season. The woods went quiet, a smell like a rutting buck rolled out of the trees, and the next morning the anchor wouldn't come up.
This story is fiction, set against real places and real history.
Prefer to read it? Download the bedtime PDF (free to share, never to sell).
The real history behind the story
67 facts, each with its source
- Marine log salvage is legislated in Part 9 of BC's Forest Act; salvage in the Vancouver Log Salvage District must follow the Forest Act and the Log Salvage Regulation. Salvors gather loose logs, mostly escaped from tows, and sell them to brokers who resell them for milling.
Source: .gov.bc.ca - Salvors must hammer-indent their mark on the ends of logs as soon as they take possession. The province issues the marks: a 'timber mark' identifies where timber came from, and logs in the water carry a separate 'marine log brand'.
Source: .gov.bc.ca - The regulation requires a hammer indentation on at least 2 log ends at the front and 2 at the back of a load, and for logs dumped into water the correct timber mark must be legibly applied on one log end of each piece.
Source: bclaws.gov.bc.ca - The log salvage regulation forbids mutilating, obliterating or making hard to distinguish a timber mark, marine log brand or log salvage identification mark, and lists cutting a salvaged log into two or more pieces among its rules. Marked logs remain the property of the mark, brand or tag holder.
Source: bclaws.gov.bc.ca - Handloggers on steep shoreline chose trees that would fall or slide into the water when cut; trees that did not reach the water were limbed, topped and moved with hand jacks.
Source: knowbc.com - Licensed handlogging in BC ran from the 1860s until the last hand logging licence was issued in 1965, so licensed handloggers in the 1970s or later would be anachronistic or illegal.
Source: viurrspace.ca - In Chinook Jargon 'chuck' means water, river or stream, and 'saltchuck' means salt water or the ocean; on the coast 'the chuck' is commonly used for the sea.
Source: fortlangley.ca - 'Saltchuck' is a documented British Columbia usage in Canadian English.
Source: dchp.arts.ubc.ca - A beachcomber's 'dog' is an iron spike with a ring, hammered into a log, to which a shorter tow line is tied to pull the log. It is not a hook on a chain.
Source: bcbusiness.ca - BC has regulated log salvage (beachcombing) since the early 1950s. Salvagers needed a permit and could sell only to a licensed salvage company. In 1954 the Vancouver Log Salvage District was created to cover the Georgia Strait shores.
Source: theglobeandmail.com - Handlogging on the BC coast ran from the 1860s until the last handlogging licence was issued in 1965.
Source: knowbc.com - A 1969 Nanaimo Historical Society talk says that from 1908 handlogging was restricted to the coast north of Cape Caution, which lies north of Port Hardy on the mainland.
Source: nanaimoarchives.ca - Boats from Port Hardy head up Goletas Channel for about 22 miles toward Cape Scott. The channel ends just east of Cape Sutil, and Cape Scott lies beyond it on the open coast.
Source: en.wikipedia.org - Nahwitti Bar runs across the west end of Goletas Channel from Vancouver Island to Hope Island, a little east of Cape Sutil. It is a shallow sandbar about 5 km wide. The safer inshore route goes behind Tatnall Reefs to Cape Sutil.
Source: waves-vagues.dfo-mpo.gc.ca - The best time to cross Nahwitti Bar is at or near slack water, and boaters usually aim for high-water slack.
Source: waves-vagues.dfo-mpo.gc.ca - The ebb over the bar runs west, so a westerly wind opposes it. The official directions warn of tide rips and overfalls, and heavy seas break across the bar in west gales.
Source: waves-vagues.dfo-mpo.gc.ca - Boaters' accounts describe kelp at Nahwitti Bar. The species is not specified.
Source: duckworksmagazine.com - Bull kelp is a large brown seaweed. It has one long stalk ending in a gas-filled bulb up to about 15 cm across, with up to about 100 blades growing from the bulb.
Source: aquariumofpacific.org - Bull kelp forms forests in shallow rocky habitats less than 30 m deep and anchors to rock with a root-like holdfast. It does not grow on soft sand.
Source: farallones.org - Nissen Bight is a white-sand beach. The steeper gravel beaches are in the smaller bays between the big bights.
Source: bcparks.ca - At full flow the current over Nahwitti Bar can reach 5.5 knots.
Source: waves-vagues.dfo-mpo.gc.ca - High-water slack at Nahwitti Bar lasts only about 12 minutes, according to a cruising guide.
Source: salishseapilot.com - The Nahwitti Bar light and whistle buoy sits 2.2 miles west of Nahwitti Point.
Source: waves-vagues.dfo-mpo.gc.ca - Boats leaving Bull Harbour on Hope Island reach the bar in about half an hour.
Source: duckworksmagazine.com - Handloggers used a Gilchrist jack to move logs into the water.
Source: search.bcarchives.gov.bc.ca - Trees that stopped short of the water were trimmed of their tops and limbs and jacked down by hand.
Source: knowbc.com - Marine log salvage on BC's coast is regulated under Part 9 of the Forest Act and the Log Salvage Regulation for the Vancouver Log Salvage District (B.C. Reg. 220/81), in force since August 1, 1981.
Source: bclaws.gov.bc.ca - A pike pole is a long pole with a metal head; the river-drive type has a spike-and-hook head. Handles were traditionally wood, and modern ones are often anodized aluminum, 8 to 12 feet long.
Source: en.wikipedia.org - A salvor works under a log salvage permit, not a licence. In the regulation, 'licence' means a receiving station licence. The permit fee is $250, and each permittee receives a salvage identification hammer for marking logs.
Source: .gov.bc.ca - Salvageable logs are abandoned logs that are adrift, cast ashore, or lying on a beach or seabed. Salvors may take timber floating free or below the high-water mark.
Source: bclaws.gov.bc.ca - Salvors need approval from the local Natural Resource Office before bucking salvaged logs ahead of scaling. A 'root buck' permit allows trimming log ends and branches, and salvors may not cut out timber marks.
Source: .gov.bc.ca - One salvor was penalized partly for root-bucking without a permit.
Source: bcfac.ca - Crown timber on Crown land cannot be salvaged if any part of it, including the roots, lies above the high-water mark, unless the minister or a forest officer consents. This applies even to downed logs.
Source: bclaws.gov.bc.ca - Logs bearing timber marks, brands or tags belong to the holder of the mark, who must be contacted about salvage rights.
Source: .gov.bc.ca - A salvor is paid remuneration by the owner for salvaging and delivering a marked log. The amount is based on the time, effort and normal expenses involved, or agreed between owner and salvor, rather than a fixed fee.
Source: bclaws.gov.bc.ca - Clear old-growth yellow cedar with tight grain and high heartwood content fetches a premium. It is prized for straight grain, colour and decay resistance.
Source: naturallywood.com - Cape Scott Park follows the northern tip of Vancouver Island from Shushartie Bay to Nissen Bight. The North Coast Trail's eastern trailhead is at Shushartie Bay, and a 1994 land-use plan recommended adding the Nahwitti–Shushartie area to the park.
Source: en.wikipedia.org - The regulation defines a 'deadhead' as a log floating with at least three-quarters of its length underwater, or with only one whole end showing. Deadheads are a known hazard to boats.
Source: bclaws.gov.bc.ca - In 2004, forest officers matched logs held by a salvor to fresh stumps above the high-water mark and seized logs worth almost $13,000. Passing off poached timber as beach salvage is a documented offence.
Source: bcfac.ca - Permittees must stamp salvaged logs with their identification hammer, including at least two logs in each boom, and must report a lost hammer to the minister immediately.
Source: .gov.bc.ca - A wrack line is a line of seaweed and other organic material and debris deposited on a beach at high tide; beaches often have several, and the highest usually comes from a spring tide or storm, not necessarily the last high tide.
Source: floridastateparks.org - Old hand-logged stumps on the BC coast carry distinctive rectangular springboard notches (notches, not holes).
Source: .gov.bc.ca - Archaeologists judge a logged stump with springboard notches to be non-Indigenous logging, unless it is tied to a clearly aboriginal feature such as a partly finished canoe.
Source: .gov.bc.ca - Yellow cedar wood has a distinct scent often likened to raw potatoes, described anywhere from pleasant to sulphur-like.
Source: wood-database.com - Yellow cedar bark is shreddy, peels in long narrow strips, and is reddish-brown to brownish-grey.
Source: research.fs.usda.gov - Yellow cedar foliage hangs in drooping, weeping sheets of overlapping flattened needles, which sets it apart at a glance from western redcedar.
Source: bcarboretum.org - Yellow cedar often lives to 1000 years and has a broad, grooved trunk that flares widely at the base; the inner bark smells like potato skins.
Source: naturallywood.com - When bucking a downed log, cut the compression side first and finish on the tension side. A log supported at both ends sags, so its top is in compression and you cut from the top first. Cutting underneath first is right only when the log is supported at one end and hangs free at the other.
Source: fs.usda.gov - Handlogging was practised on the banks of many protected waterways of the BC coast beginning in the 1860s; on steep shorelines loggers selected trees that would fall or slide into the water when cut.
Source: knowbc.com - Log salvage is a licensed, regulated trade; in 1954 the Ministry of Forests set up the Vancouver Log Salvage District, covering shorelines on both sides of the Georgia Strait and up the Fraser River as far as Hope.
Source: bcbusiness.ca - Licensed salvors could sell stray logs to Gulf Log Salvage Co-operative, which set prices, found buyers and shared profits among member forestry companies; a 2001 Ministry of Finance audit vindicated beachcombers' complaints about pricing.
Source: bcbusiness.ca - Marine Communications and Traffic Services (MCTS) Comox closed in May 2016, with staff offered jobs in Victoria or Prince Rupert; before then Comox covered northern Vancouver Island waters, so a story set before May 2016 should name Comox (or Tofino), not Prince Rupert.
Source: cbc.ca - The consolidation closed MCTS centres in Vancouver, Tofino and Comox, leaving Prince Rupert as B.C.'s other remaining marine traffic-monitoring centre.
Source: biv.com - On the North Coast Trail, campsites run east to west: Shushartie Bay, Skinner Creek, Nahwitti River, Cape Sutil, Irony Creek (Shuttleworth Bight) and Laura Creek, so Shuttleworth Bight lies east of Cape Scott and west of Nahwitti.
Source: happiestoutdoors.ca - Shuttleworth Bight has a campsite on the west side of Irony Creek, in the middle of the bight.
Source: vancouverisland.com - Handlogging lasted about a century, from the 1860s until the last hand logging licence was issued in 1965, so a handlogger working legally after 1965 would be an anachronism.
Source: viurrspace.ca - The North Coast Trail was completed in May 2008 after the Nahwitti-Shushartie area was added to Cape Scott Provincial Park; before 2008 the Nahwitti area was not part of the park.
Source: vancouverisland.com - Handlogging was practised on the banks of many protected waterways of the BC coast from the 1860s. On steep shorelines, loggers selected trees that would fall or slide into the water when cut. The last handlogging licence was issued in 1965.
Source: knowbc.com - In 1908 handlogging was restricted to the North Coast above Cape Caution. By 1914, 80 to 90% of handlogging took place on that north coast. Port Hardy and Goletas Channel appear to lie south of Cape Caution, so legal handlogging there after 1908 may be anachronistic.
Source: nanaimoarchives.ca - Log salvage permit rules apply inside the Vancouver Log Salvage District. Outside the District no permit is required, but salvors need a client number with the ministry and a scale site linked to their salvage operations.
Source: .gov.bc.ca - Under BC law a deadhead is a log that floats with at least 3/4 of its length totally submerged, or with the entire diameter of one end out of the water. It need not be standing on end.
Source: bclaws.gov.bc.ca - Deadheads are a known boating hazard on the BC coast: nearly invisible logs floating vertically under the water that can seriously damage a boat.
Source: pocomarine.com - Western red cedar is one of the lightest commercial softwoods, about 21 lb per cubic foot oven-dry, so it floats high, higher than fir. It is not as light as cork, green (freshly cut) cedar floats lower than dry cedar, and it can become waterlogged.
Source: realcedar.com - A bitt is a strong post of wood or iron projecting above a ship's deck, usually in pairs, used for securing cables and towing lines. Steel suits a modern boat; an older one might have wood or iron.
Source: dictionary.com - Transport Canada directs distress calls to VHF channel 16 (156.8 MHz), with a DSC alert on channel 70 for DSC-equipped radios where the service is offered.
Source: tc.canada.ca - Handloggers used jacks, such as the Gilchrist Jack, to move logs into the water.
Source: search.bcarchives.gov.bc.ca - BC salvage rules refer to logs bearing a timber mark or a registered marine log brand, or bearing an ownership tag.
Source: bclaws.gov.bc.ca
Transcript
Read the full story
I still work salvage. Two years on, I'm out of Hardy most weeks on a different boat with a different skipper, and I'm still the one on deck with the pike pole and the hammer. The only thing that's changed is this. I won't hammer a log dog, the steel spike we tow by, into anything that has roots. Not a stump, not a windfall with dirt still on it, not a tree that's halfway into the chuck, the sea, the way the old-timers say it, and still holding on to the bank. The guys I work with now think it's a superstition I picked up from my old man. They're half right.
The morning it started, Ruth had the kitchen light on before five. I came down with my sea bag and found my father already up, sitting at the table in his housecoat with his feet in a basin of warm water. His ankles had been swelling bad that month. The doctor in Hardy called it fluid. My dad called it the bill coming due for forty years of standing in cold water.
"You're taking my saw," he said.
It was by the door in its old wooden case. A heavy orange Stihl he'd bought new in the seventies, back when he handlogged the inlets, falling trees by hand right into the water, no roads, no machines, with a partner and an old boat and whatever the tide brought in. I'd rebuilt the carburetor on it the winter before. It ran better than my own.
"Vic's is down," I said. "His bar's bent. I'll bring it back in one piece."
"I'm not worried about the saw." He reached for his tea and stopped halfway, breathing. Ruth put it closer to him without saying anything. She'd been doing that kind of thing for a year, while I was gone four and five days at a stretch. She never once made me feel bad for going. That's the kind of person she is.
I'd been on the water twenty years by then. Seiners first, then trolling, then the last six on salvage boats working drift logs along the outer coast. I was good at it. I could look at a log from fifty meters and tell you the species, how long it had been in the water, and whether it would float or sink once you dragged it off the beach. Lumber prices went through the roof in twenty twenty-one. Lumber came back down. Old cedar never did, and a good trip on the Sitka Rose paid more than I'd made in a month on the seiners. The trips were short. I could be home between them. That was the whole reason I was on that boat.
I picked up the saw case. My dad watched me do it.
"Owen."
"Yeah."
"Nothing with roots."
He'd been saying that since I was a kid. Drift is fair, he'd say. The sea took it, you can take it from the sea. Anything still in the ground belongs to somebody, even if you can't see who. I'd always heard it the way you hear "wear your life jacket." Good advice from an old man.
"I know, Dad."
He held my eye a second longer than he needed to. Then he nodded, and Ruth walked me to the truck.
Three of us went out through Goletas Channel that morning. Vic Thorne at the wheel, fifty-eight, thirty years beachcombing, a coffee in one hand and a story going the whole time. Kyle Penner on deck with me, twenty-three, in his second season, so happy to be out there he'd stand at the rail for an hour just watching the water. A pod of orcas picked us up off Hope Island and ran with us a while. Kyle about lost his mind.
We timed the bar right. Nahwitti Bar sits off Cape Sutil, shallow and wide, and you cross it at slack water or you don't cross it at all. A westerly against the ebb out there stands the swell straight up into breakers. That morning it was flat calm. The water lay like oil. Vic eased us over at eight knots and called it the nicest crossing he'd had all year.
I was at the stern with my coffee when I noticed the kelp.
There's a long bed of bull kelp on the inside edge of the bar. At slack it should hang loose, the heads floating every which way. That morning every single strand was laid out flat and pointing the same direction. West. Back toward Cape Scott. Pulled tight, as if a hard current was running out of the channel. But there was no current. I looked at the water against the hull. Nothing moving.
An eddy off the cape, I figured. Some backwash I couldn't see.
I finished my coffee and went forward to help Kyle with the lines.
Vic put us on our first beach a little past noon, a gravel pocket in Nissen Bight, an hour short of the cape, with a jam of drift piled along the top of it. The tide was coming up. On that coast you work the flood. You go ashore while the water's low, pick your logs, and get them ready so the boat can pull them off when the tide floats them.
Kyle and I took the skiff in with the dog bag and two sledges. A log dog is a steel spike with a hook on it, on a short chain. You hammer two or three into a log, shackle the chains to the towline, and when the water comes up the boat backs off and drags it free. I picked out a hemlock and two fir, sound wood, well below the high-water line. Kyle drove his first dog crooked and I showed him how to start it with a light tap before you swing.
"How do you know they'll float?" he said.
"Look at the bark. Look how high it rides on the gravel when the swash gets under it. Those ones have been up on the gravel since the winter storms. Sun and wind have dried them out."
By two we had three logs off and rafted behind the Rose. I worked them from the stern with the pike pole, a long ash pole with a steel spike and hook on the end, pushing them into line so they wouldn't knock the hull. It was honest work. Drift is the sea's. That's what the licence is for. And the licence has rules. You don't cut the roots off. You don't cut the top off. You don't buck a log on the beach without permission. A log comes in the way the sea gave it to you.
The second beach was where it turned.
There was a big spruce up past the drift line, lying on moss, ferns grown up through the branches. It had come down in a winter storm, maybe two years before, and the sea had never touched it. Vic walked up to it and slapped it like a horse.
"Dog it," he said.
Kyle looked at me. Salvage is for what the tide has taken. Wood below the high-water line. Anything above it is standing timber, whether it's upright or not, and it isn't ours.
"That's above the line, Vic," I said.
"It'll be below the line when we drag it down there."
He laughed when he said it. Vic had a good laugh. He'd been beachcombing for thirty years, and he knew the coast better than any man I'd worked for. He also had a bank loan on the Rose and a buyer in Port McNeill who paid cash for cedar and didn't ask questions.
The next log had a timber mark on the end. Every company hammers its brand into the butts of its logs, and a stamped log, wherever it washes up, still belongs to them. You report it to the owner, and they pay you a salvage fee for bringing it in. Vic handed me my father's saw.
"Take the stamp off that end."
I stood there with the case in my hand.
"Owen. Do you know what yellow cedar's going for since the pandemic? Old growth, clear grain? I've got guys calling me. That log's six grand. With the stamp on it, it's three hundred."
So I cut it. I want to be honest about that. I took a thin cookie off that end, two inches with the stamp on it, in about forty seconds and flung it up into the thick waxy brush along the top of the beach. Kyle didn't say anything for an hour.
Around three, with the light already going flat, Vic took us around the cape.
"I'm going to show you boys something," he said. "And you don't tell anybody where it is."
The cove was small. A crescent of grey sand, maybe two hundred meters across, with a rock point on each side and old timber standing right down to the edge of the bank. Technically we'd been in Cape Scott Park since Shushartie Bay. Vic worked those beaches anyway. Drift below the tide line is drift, he said, park or no park, and nobody's ever come out to tell him different. But there's no trail down to this cove, no campsite, nothing on the chart but a contour line. "Nobody lands here," he said. "Nobody but me."
"Park line's back there."
"So we're in the park," Kyle said.
"We're in a cove."
I didn't argue. I was looking at the beach.
Every beach on that coast has drift on it. Every single one. Logs stacked three deep, root wads, planks, rope, floats, plastic. The storms throw it up all winter. This beach had nothing. The sand was clean from the waterline to the bank. Not a stick. Not a shell. There wasn't even a wrack line, the band of dead kelp and junk that marks where the last high tide stopped. It looked swept.
"Where's all the wood?" I said.
"Up there." Vic nodded at the bank. "That's the honey hole. Old-timers in Hardy won't anchor in there. Some story about a handlogger. Their loss."
Above the beach, half buried in moss, was a stump. A big one, two meters across, so grown over with ferns and brush that I took it for a boulder at first. Then I saw the notches. Two square holes chopped into the side of it, chest high on a man standing on the slope.
Springboard notches. Handloggers cut those to stand on boards above the swell of the trunk. Nobody had done that on this coast since my dad's time.
Somebody had come into this cove a long time ago and taken a tree.
And no drift had landed on that beach since.
We ate on the back deck while the tide came up. Kyle made the sandwiches, cheese and pickle on white bread, and put too much mustard on all of them. I sat on the hatch cover with my dad's saw across my knees and touched up the chain with a round file. Four strokes a tooth, same as he taught me. The orcas had followed us around the cape. They were holding a few hundred meters off the mouth of the cove, blowing every minute or so. Kyle kept getting up to look.
"They don't usually hang around like that," he said.
"Maybe they like your sandwiches."
Vic finished his and wiped his hands on his jeans. "Come on. Bring the saw."
We took the skiff in. The sand at the waterline was hard and fine and didn't hold a footprint long. Vic walked us to the north end of the cove, past the old stump, to where the bank rose steep under the trees.
I'd seen the log from the boat and taken it for drift. It wasn't.
It was a yellow cedar, the biggest I'd ever stood next to. It had come down off the bank in some storm and lay angled across the upper beach, its crown out on the sand, its trunk a meter and a half through at the butt. The bark was grey and shaggy and peeling in long strips. Where a branch had torn off, the wood showed pale yellow, almost gold. It had a smell, that wood. Sharp and clean, a bit like a cut potato.
And at the top of the bank, the roots were still in the ground. It hadn't snapped. It had tipped. Half the root plate had torn up out of the dirt, but the other half was still down in the hillside, roots as thick as my leg running back into the moss. The foliage on the crown was still green, those drooping flat sprays yellow cedar has.
That tree was alive.
"Clear grain," Vic said. "Look at it. No knots for twenty meters. That's forty grand lying there, boys. Maybe fifty to the right buyer."
"It's still rooted," I said.
"It's half rooted. Next big blow, it'll come the rest of the way down and wash out to sea. Then it's drift and some other guy gets it. I'm just early."
Kyle said, "Vic, we're in the park."
"And there's nobody here but us."
I looked at the roots. I could hear my dad at the kitchen table. Nothing with roots.
Vic put his hand on my shoulder. Not hard. Friendly. "Owen. You're the best cutter I've got. Take it off at the bank, right above the root plate, and we'll dog it and pull it on the high water. Twenty minutes."
I'd like to tell you I argued longer than I did. He was the skipper. I'd already cut the mark off one log that day. And part of me, I'll say it plain, wanted to see a tree like that on the towline.
Vic went back out to the boat to get the winch ready. Kyle came up the bank with me and stood off to the side with the pike pole, watching.
I picked my spot. The trunk sat on the edge of the bank, held down by the roots, so the top of it was under strain. I made a shallow cut underneath first, so the wood wouldn't split when it let go. Then I went in from the top.
My dad's saw ran sweet. Chips came off in long yellow ribbons. The smell of the cedar came up thick and clean around me.
I was maybe a third of the way through when I smelled something else.
It came down out of the trees all at once. Heavy and musky and rank, like a buck in the rut. I've hunted deer since I was twelve. I know that smell. This was that, but so strong my eyes watered. I lifted off the throttle.
"You smell that?" Kyle said.
That's when I noticed the birds. All afternoon the woods behind the cove had been loud. Thrushes, wrens, a pair of ravens talking somewhere up the hill. Now there was nothing. The saw idled in my hands, and past it there was no sound at all. Not a bird. Not a branch moving.
Kyle was staring up into the trees.
"Owen," he said. "There's somebody there."
I looked.
The timber above the cove was old growth, big trunks standing far apart with dark ground between them. About forty meters up the slope, between two hemlocks, something was standing. Tall. Taller than a man, and dark, darker than the shade around it. I couldn't make out a shape to it. Just height, and darkness, and the sense that it was facing us.
I blinked.
It was closer. Thirty meters. Between a different pair of trunks.
I hadn't seen it move. There was no walking, no crossing the ground in between. It was there, and then it was nearer, like frames cut out of a film.
"Bear," I said. My voice came out wrong. "It's a bear standing up."
"That's not a bear."
It was at twenty meters. Same thing. Here, and then here. The musk rolled down over us so thick I could taste it.
I don't know why I did what I did next. I think I just wanted it finished. I opened the throttle and put the saw back into the cut.
The tree took the bar like it was trying to hold it. I leaned on it. The chain screamed. The wood cracked once, deep inside, and then the last of it went with a sound like a rifle shot, and the whole trunk dropped a few inches onto the sand and settled.
I killed the saw.
When I looked up, there was nothing between the trees.
Kyle hadn't moved. His knuckles were white on the pike pole.
Out on the water, Vic gave two blasts on the horn. The tide was up.
We dogged it. We shackled it to the towline, and Vic put the Rose in reverse and dragged that cedar down the bank and off the beach and into the water.
Up in the woods, the birds didn't start again. Not that evening. Not at all.
Vic anchored us in the middle of the cove for the night. Six meters of water, clean sand bottom, the towline slack and the logs rafted off the stern. He said it was the calmest anchorage north of Hardy. He was in a good mood. He opened a beer and stood looking at the cedar in the last of the light like it was a new truck.
The orcas were gone from the mouth. I didn't see them leave.
After supper I borrowed the sat phone and took it out on the bow. Ruth answered on the third ring.
"How's the trip?"
"Good. Long day. How's he doing?"
"Tired. His ankles are worse." She paused. "He had a funny turn this afternoon. He was asleep in his chair, and around four he woke up all at once and asked who'd left the back door open. It wasn't open. He wanted me to check twice."
Four. I'd been on the bank with the saw at four.
"He's fine now," she said. "He wants to talk to you."
I heard the phone change hands, and his breathing, short and wet.
"Where are you?"
I told him. Around the cape, a little cove inside the park. Bare beach. Old stump with springboard notches on the bank.
He didn't say anything for so long I thought the call had dropped.
"Dad?"
"Did you take one standing?"
"What?"
"Owen. Did you take one that was standing."
I looked back along the deck at the cedar. "No, Dad. Just drift."
Another silence. I could hear him breathing.
"I know that place," he said. "Listen to me. Whatever is taken from there without leave, it takes back. And you don't leave till it has."
"Dad, it's just a cove."
"When you get in," he said, "you come see me. First thing. Before you wash. You promise me that."
"I promise."
Ruth came back on and said he was getting upset and she'd better settle him. I told her I loved her. I told her I'd be home Thursday. I meant every word of that.
I went below and washed my hands. I'd been smelling the musk on them since the beach. I used dish soap, then the orange hand cleaner Vic kept by the sink, then dish soap again. I scrubbed until my knuckles were red. I'd promised him before I washed, and I knew it was already too late for that. It didn't matter. I held them up to my face.
Buck. Rank and thick, right down in the skin, under the nails.
Kyle was sitting at the galley table watching me. He didn't say anything. He'd held the pike pole. He hadn't touched the saw.
I slept badly. Around two in the morning I woke up and went out on deck to check the anchor, because that's what you do. The night was dead calm. No moon. The water around the boat was black and flat, and the cedar lay on the towline behind us, pale in the dark.
The air on deck smelled of musk.
Not faint. Not drifting off the shore on a breeze. There wasn't any breeze. It was right there, on the deck, around the hatch, the way it had been on the bank with the trees standing over me.
I looked at the shore. I couldn't see the treeline. Just black on black.
I went back inside and locked the wheelhouse door. I had never once locked that door at anchor.
I didn't sleep after that. I sat in the wheelhouse with the lights off and watched the black where the beach should be until it went grey.
Around five-thirty Vic came up the ladder in his socks, scratching his chest. "You're up early."
"Couldn't sleep."
"That's the cedar," he said. "Too excited." He fired up the engine and let it warm. "We'll get the hook up and catch the slack on the bar this afternoon. Home by dark tomorrow."
It was a pretty morning. Still flat calm, mist lying in the tops of the trees, the water in the cove like glass. Kyle came out on deck with a coffee and made a happy sound, and I looked where he was looking. The orcas were back. Five or six of them, holding off the mouth of the cove, the big male's fin standing straight up out of the mist.
"They waited for us," Kyle said.
I went forward to run the windlass. The chain came up wet and clean, link over link, until it went bar tight, straight up and down off the bow. The windlass groaned and stopped.
"Snagged," I called back.
"On sand?" Vic leaned out the wheelhouse door. "There's nothing down there."
He was right. I'd seen it on the sounder the night before. Six meters of clean sand, no rock, no wreck, no old cable. I let out a few meters and Vic tried to break it free the usual way, motoring up over the anchor, then backing down hard to pull it out the other direction.
On the third try the engine bogged. There was a heavy thump under the stern, a shudder up through the deck, and the shaft stopped dead. Vic shut her down quick before he burned something.
"Prop's fouled," he said.
"On what?"
He didn't answer. There's no kelp in a sand cove. Kelp grows on rock.
We kept an old drysuit aboard for clearing props. I pulled it on, with a weight belt, the hood, a mask and a dive knife strapped to my calf, and Kyle tied a line around my waist. The water that time of year was maybe nine degrees. I went in off the swim step and the cold took my breath for a second, even through the suit.
I ducked under the stern.
The water was clear. Clearer than I'd ever seen it on that coast. The morning light came down through it green and soft, and under the Rose's hull the shaft and propeller were wrapped solid in bull kelp. Long brown stems, the kind with the bulb on the end, the kind that had been laid out flat and pointing west on the bar the morning before. It was wound around the shaft so tight the stems had gone flat and shiny, packed down into the gap between the prop and the hull.
I pulled my knife and started cutting. It was like cutting wet rope. Then like cutting cable. I sawed at one stem for half a minute before it parted.
I'd cleared fouled props before, plenty of them. When a prop picks up a line or a strand of kelp, it winds it on in the direction the shaft turns. Every time. That's just how it works.
This kelp was wound the other way.
I came up for air. Kyle was crouched on the swim step. "How bad?"
"Bad," I said, and went back down.
This time I didn't go straight to the shaft. I followed the anchor chain with my eyes, down from the bow, through all that clear green water. I could see right to the bottom. The chain ran straight down to the sand.
The anchor was lying there on its side.
It wasn't dug in. It wasn't hooked on anything. The flukes weren't even buried. It was a fifty-kilo plow anchor lying on top of bare sand, and there was nothing on it and nothing around it, and the windlass on the Rose hadn't been able to lift it.
I hung there under the boat and stared at it.
It wasn't snagged. It was being held.
That's when I noticed the sound. Underwater, you can hear orcas a long way off. All the time I'd been under, I'd been hearing them without thinking about it. Clicks, and long squealing whistles, and a sort of creaking, coming through the water from the mouth of the cove. It's a busy sound. A family talking.
It stopped.
Not faded. Stopped, all at once, in the middle of a call. Orcas go quiet when they're hunting. That's the only time. But they weren't hunting. They were leaving.
The light changed. Something passed between me and the bottom.
It was a shadow. Just a shadow, at first, a long darkness moving over the sand under the boat, slow, from the bow toward the stern. I waited for the end of it. The Sitka Rose is fifteen meters long, and I watched that shadow go the whole length of her and keep going. It was deeper than the hull and higher than the sand, and I could not see the edges of it. I couldn't tell you what color it was. It was just the water there being darker than it should have been.
The water pushed against me. A slow, heavy push, like something big had moved its weight. Above me the hull of the Rose lifted. I saw it. The whole boat rose maybe a hand's width and settled again, and the anchor chain swung once and went still.
I came up so fast I hit my head on the swim step.
Kyle was pulling on the line. Vic was there too, both of them hauling me up onto the stern. I tore off the mask. I could hardly get the words out.
"Something's under the boat."
Kyle wasn't looking at me. He was looking at the mouth of the cove. "The whales," he said. "Owen, look at the whales."
They were running. All of them, straight out to sea, low and fast, not blowing, the big male in front. I watched them go until they were specks in the mist. Then they were gone.
And the air had changed. The musk was gone. In its place there was a smell I knew from summers on the water, the smell that comes right before a lightning storm. Crisp and sharp, so clean it hurt to breathe. And under that, rain hitting dry rock, the very first drops after a long hot spell. There wasn't a cloud in the sky.
"What the hell was that," Vic said quietly. It was the first time I'd heard him not sound sure of something.
"I told you," I said. "Something's under the boat. Something big, Vic. Bigger than us. The anchor's not stuck. It's lying on the sand. It's not hooked on anything."
"Then it's stuck in the sand."
"It's lying on top of it."
He looked at me a long time. Then he went into the wheelhouse and turned up the radio.
The weather channel was running. A gale warning for the west coast of the Island, northern half. Westerlies thirty-five knots by tomorrow afternoon, rising to forty-five overnight. Seas building to four meters.
"Call them," I said. "Call the Coast Guard."
"And tell them what?" He kept his voice down so Kyle wouldn't hear, but Kyle heard. "That my anchor won't come up? That there's a big fish? They're not sending a boat for a fouled hook, Owen. They'll tell me to cut it and go."
"Then tell them the truth."
"The truth." He pointed back over the stern at the cedar lying on the towline, gold where the bark had torn. "The truth is we're inside a park with a standing yellow cedar on the line. They come out here, they see that, I lose the boat. You want to be on that report? It was your saw."
I didn't say anything.
He picked up the handset anyway, and called Coast Guard radio out of Prince Rupert, and told them his anchor was fouled and he might need to leave it.
The voice on the other end was calm and polite. Was the vessel in distress? Was anyone injured? Was the vessel taking on water?
"Negative," Vic said. "Negative. Negative."
They read him the gale warning and told him to keep a listening watch.
Vic hung up the handset. Behind him, through the wheelhouse window, the cove was perfectly still. Not a ripple anywhere.
My father's voice was in my head. You don't leave till it has.
Vic wanted to try the windlass one more time. It didn't move. He stood at the bow looking down at the chain going straight into the water, and then he said, "Let it run."
"You're leaving the anchor?"
"I'm buoying it. I'll come back for it in the spring with a bigger boat."
Kyle went below to the chain locker and knocked the pin out of the shackle on the bitter end, where the chain is fixed inside the boat. I tied an old orange float to the last link and we let the whole thing go over the bow. It rattled out and was gone. The float bobbed there in the middle of the cove, still as a painted thing.
Then I went back in the water.
I didn't want to. My head was pounding where I'd hit it, and every time I looked down at the green under the stern my stomach turned over. But the Rose wasn't going anywhere with the shaft wrapped, and I was the one who knew how to clear it.
This time it came off easy.
I took the knife to the first stem and it parted in two strokes. The next one too. The kelp that had been as hard as cable twenty minutes before was soft and slick and ordinary, and in ten minutes I had the whole mess cut away and drifting down to the sand in pieces. I looked along the bottom while I worked. Bare sand. The orange float's line going down to the anchor. Nothing else. No shadow. Just green water and light.
I came up and hung on the swim step for a while.
I'd been up all night. I'd been smelling things since the beach. I'd hit my head. I'm not a man who sees things, and I started to wonder, hanging there in the cold, if I'd just seen one.
"Clear?" Vic said.
"Clear."
He started her up and put her in gear. The shaft turned sweet and smooth. We took up the slack on the towline and the logs swung in behind us, the cedar at the end of the string, and the Sitka Rose motored out of that cove like it was any other morning.
The sun came out over the cape as we cleared the point. Within half an hour we were in open water with the swell starting to lift us, long and easy, and the mist burning off, and the cove gone behind the headland.
Vic laughed. A big one, from the belly.
"Bad bottom," he said. "That's all that was. There's clay under that sand, sucked the anchor down. And kelp's kelp. Comes in on the current. I've seen a prop wrapped worse in Hardy harbor."
"The anchor was lying on top," I said.
"You hit your head, Owen."
"And the whales?"
"Whales do what they want." He held up a hand. "Look. I've been coming into that cove for fifteen years. Never had a lick of trouble. We had a weird morning. Now we're out."
Kyle had been coiling a line on the back deck. He dropped it.
"Cut it loose," he said.
Vic looked at him.
"The cedar. Cut it loose. Let it go. Please. I saw something in those trees yesterday, Vic. Owen saw it. And whatever was under the boat this morning, the whales saw it. They ran. You know what it takes to make orcas run?"
"Kid—"
"We don't need it. We've got five other logs. Let it go."
"I'm not cutting forty grand off the end of my line because you got spooked by a bear." Vic's voice stayed friendly, but there was something hard under it. "You want to go home? We're going home. Sit down."
Kyle looked at me. I didn't say anything. I want to be honest about that, too. Out there in the sun with the engine running, Vic sounded right.
I took the sat phone back to the stern.
Ruth picked up on the first ring this time. "He's been asking for you all morning," she said. "He won't settle. Owen, what's going on?"
"Put him on."
My dad's breathing was worse. I could hear him working for every word.
"You took one."
"Yeah," I said. "I took one, Dad. A yellow cedar. It was still rooted. Vic told me to cut it and I cut it. With your saw."
He was quiet for a while.
"I want to tell you about Ray," he said.
Ray Dunn had been his partner in the seventies. I knew the name. There was a picture of the two of them in our hall, young and bearded, standing on a raft of logs. I'd asked about Ray once when I was a boy, and my dad had said he drowned, and that was all I ever got.
"He didn't drown," my dad said. "Nineteen seventy-nine. We were short that year. Ray knew that cove. He said there was a cedar there standing right on the bank, so close to the water we could fall it straight onto the beach. I didn't want to. I said nothing with roots. My father used to say that. Ray laughed at me."
"Dad, the stump. The springboard notches."
"That's Ray's cut. I held the boards."
The swell lifted the stern and set it down. The logs rode up behind us on the towline.
"We got it on the chain on the high tide. In the morning the anchor wouldn't come up. Three days. Couldn't move. Kelp in the wheel, kelp in the intake. The radio quit. And at night you could smell it on deck. The animal smell." He stopped and breathed. "On the third night Ray said it was his tree. He'd cut it. He said he was going to go up there and settle it. That's what he said. Settle it. He took the skiff in. I watched him walk up past the stump into the trees. He didn't take a light."
"What happened?"
"Nothing happened. He didn't come back. In the morning the anchor came up like nothing was wrong. The log was gone off the chain. Dogs and all. I looked for Ray for two days. I never told anybody but your mother. I said he went over the side."
I was standing with the phone against my ear, looking back at the cedar. The sun was on it. The cut end, my cut, was pale and raw.
The smell came up around me.
Not around the boat. Around me. Lightning and first rain. Sharp in my nose, cold on my face, and the air everywhere else on deck still smelling of diesel and salt. Kyle was ten feet away and didn't look up.
"Owen," my dad said. "You listen to me. You give it back. It has to be given, Owen. Not lost. Not stolen off you in the night. If it drifts off it'll only come back to you. You let it go with your own hands. The wood, and whatever cut it. We never gave ours. Ray gave himself."
Under my feet, the Rose shuddered once, hard, from the keel up.
The engine coughed.
And stopped.
Vic was down in the engine room before I'd even hung up the phone. I heard him swearing through the hatch. Kyle came aft and stood next to me.
"What did your dad say?"
"He said give it back."
Kyle looked at the cedar, then at me, and didn't say anything.
It took Vic forty minutes to find it. The sea strainer, the little basket that keeps junk out of the cooling water, was packed solid. He held it up for us on the back deck. Bull kelp, the same brown stems, wound into a ball so tight he had to pry it out with a screwdriver. That strainer sits inside the hull. The only way in is a pipe about as thick as my thumb.
"Current kelp," I said. I didn't mean it kindly.
Vic didn't answer.
She started again, but she ran hot. Every time Vic took her past half throttle the temperature needle climbed, so we crept east along the north side of the cape at four knots with the tow dragging behind. Four knots meant we weren't making the bar on the afternoon slack. By the time we got there the tide would be on the ebb, and the swell from that gale was already coming ahead of it. You could see it on the horizon to the west. Long grey hills of water, getting taller.
"We'll tuck in for the night," Vic said. "Cross on the morning slack. Before the wind."
He took us into Shuttleworth Bight, thirty-some kilometres east of the cove. A long beach, open timber behind it, a couple of hours short of the bar at towing speed. We had no anchor, so he dug out the spare, a little Danforth that lived under the bunk. It was meant for lunch stops, not a boat towing six logs. He set it in the lee of the point in four meters.
"It'll hold," he said. "There's no wind."
There wasn't, yet. It was early evening, and the bight was quiet except for the swell booming on the outer rocks.
I went out on the back deck with the binoculars. I told myself I was checking the tow. I wasn't. I was looking at the trees.
I saw it almost right away.
Up at the top of the beach, back in the first line of timber. A tall dark shape standing between two trunks. I lowered the glasses. Without them it was just shadow. I put them back up.
It was further along. Two trunks over. Then two more. Keeping pace with the boat as the swell swung us on the anchor line. Never in the open. Never crossing the gaps.
"Kyle."
He took the binoculars. He looked a long time. Then he handed them back without a word and went inside and sat down at the galley table with his hands flat on it.
I took the glasses to Vic in the wheelhouse.
"Look at the treeline," I said. "Just look."
He didn't take them. He didn't even turn his head. He sat in the skipper's chair staring straight out the front window at open water.
"I'm not looking at the trees," he said.
That was all. Not "there's nothing there." Not "you hit your head." I'm not looking at the trees. I stood there with the binoculars and understood that Vic Thorne knew something, and had known it for a while, and had decided it didn't matter as much as forty grand.
After dark he took a flashlight and a folding chair out to the stern and sat with the beam on the cedar. He said somebody had to watch the tow. He'd been telling us all day there was nothing to watch it for.
Around ten the land breeze came down off the hills, the way it does on a still night. It came down over the timber and across the bight and onto the boat, and it carried the musk. Thick and rank. It filled the wheelhouse even with the door shut. Kyle pulled his shirt up over his nose. Vic, out on the stern, never moved.
I went to bed in my clothes. I lay in the bunk and listened.
At one in the morning the hull rang.
It was a deep blow, right under me, through the planking and into the mattress. Not a log knocking. The logs were astern. This was under the keel, and the whole boat lurched sideways, and something in the galley fell and smashed.
I went up the ladder. Vic was on his feet with the flashlight, swinging it across the water. The cedar was riding at the end of the tow where it belonged. The other logs too. The water was black and flat and there was nothing in it.
"What was that," I said.
"Deadhead," Vic said. A waterlogged log floating on end, just the top showing. "Drifted into us."
"We're at anchor."
I went to the stern rail to look down along the hull. I leaned out. And the second blow came.
Harder. From the other side. The deck went out from under me and the rail hit me in the stomach and I was over it from the waist up, looking straight down into black water a meter below my face. The smell came up off it, lightning and rain, so sharp it stung my eyes. Something moved in that water. Not a shape. A long slow turning, like the water itself had a back.
Then a fist was in my jacket, hauling me backwards onto the deck. Kyle. He'd come up behind me barefoot. We lay there on the wet planks breathing.
"Stay off the rail," he said. His voice was shaking. "Owen. Stay off the rail."
Vic hadn't moved to help. He was standing with his light on the cedar.
Nobody slept after that. The bumps didn't come again. Around four the land breeze died and the musk thinned out, and the first grey came up behind the hills. I went out on deck to check the tow, keeping well back from the rail.
The string was short.
I counted. The hemlock. The two firs. The spruce. The log with no mark. At the end of the towline the last shackle hung down into the water with a short length of chain on it. One link was open. Not broken. Opened, the steel bent back like a hairpin.
The cedar was gone.
"Vic," I said. Then louder. "Vic!"
He came out of the wheelhouse. He saw the chain. His face went grey. He ran to the stern and swept his eyes across the bight, out toward the open water where the ebb would have carried it.
"It'll be on the beach," he said. "It'll be out on the point. It can't have—"
Kyle said, "Owen."
He was at the side of the boat, beside the wheelhouse. Pointing down.
I went over.
On that coast there's a thing called a deadhead. A log that's soaked up so much water it floats on end, straight up and down, with just the top showing. You can't see them till you're on them. They've holed more boats on that coast than anybody likes to count.
The cedar was floating upright, a meter off our hull, right beside the wheelhouse door. Upcurrent of the boat. Upwind of where it should have drifted. Just the end of it showing above the water, round and pale and raw.
My cut. Facing up at me.
The dogs were still in it. Their chains hung down into the water.
It had not been in the water long enough to sink one inch. That was green wood, cut alive the day before. Cedar floats like a cork even green. It had no business standing on end.
Vic was the first to move. He went for the pike pole.
"Get me a shackle and a length of chain," he said.
Neither of us went.
"Owen."
"I'm not touching it."
He looked at Kyle. Kyle shook his head. So Vic did it himself. He leaned out over the side with the pike pole, hooked one of the hanging dog chains, and walked that cedar aft along the hull, hand over hand, grunting. It came easy. Too easy for a log that size. He got a new shackle on the chain and pinned it to the end of the towline, and when it was done he stood there breathing hard with the pole in his hands.
"There," he said. "Now nobody touch my tow."
I went below to get coffee going and found what had smashed in the night. The sat phone. It had been in its cradle on the galley shelf, and now it was on the floor in three pieces with the screen cracked across.
Then the engine wouldn't start. The strainer again. The same tight brown ball. Vic cleared it, and she started, and ran ten minutes and quit. He cleared it again. By the time she would hold an idle the slack on the bar had come and gone, and the ebb was running, and out past the point the swell had grown into something you could hear from the deck.
The wind came at three in the afternoon. Right on the forecast, and all at once. The bight went from grey to white in about twenty minutes. Rain came sideways off the point. The little Danforth held for an hour and then started to drag. I could feel it through the deck, a slow jerk, jerk, jerk as it skipped along the bottom toward the beach.
"Keep her running," Vic said. "Just enough to ease the line."
So we kept her running. And every forty minutes or so the temperature needle started to climb and I went down into the engine room with a flashlight and pulled the strainer.
It was full every time. Bull kelp, wound tight. In a bight full of sand, in a gale, coming up a pipe the width of my thumb. I'd throw it in a bucket and screw the lid back down and climb up, and forty minutes later I'd go down again. By dark the bucket was half full.
Around seven Vic tried the radio. He was going to call it in, I think. A dragging anchor in a gale is a reason to call. Every channel was the same. A long soft hiss, like surf. No weather. No traffic. Not even the automatic broadcast out of Prince Rupert that never stops.
He put the handset back on its hook very gently.
Then he took the flashlight and his folding chair and went out on the stern in his rain gear, and sat down facing the cedar.
I want to tell you what that night was like.
The Rose rolled hard on the short line. Rain hammered the wheelhouse windows. Every time I went out to check the tow I kept one hand on the house and stayed well off the rail, the way Kyle had told me. Vic sat in his chair with the beam on the cedar. It rode at the end of the string, behind the spruce and the log with no mark.
Until it didn't.
Around ten I came out and the towline between the logs was slack in the water. The cedar was right off the stern. Two meters from Vic's knees. Riding upright again, the pale cut end turned up, the rain bouncing off it. The other five logs were strung out behind where they should be. The cedar was not.
Vic didn't look surprised. He just moved the flashlight down a little to keep it on the wood.
The bumps came back after that.
Not one. A rhythm. A long, heavy shove from under the keel, the whole boat lifting and leaning, and then nothing for a few minutes, and then another. Each one harder. Each one closer to the stern. Down in the engine room the bilge water sloshed back and forth and dishes walked out of the galley rack one by one.
And the musk came aboard.
It came in with the wind off the land, the way it had the night before. But this time it didn't thin out. It came down the companionway and settled in the cabin. It was in the bunks. It was on the pillow I'd slept on. When I went down into the engine room it was down there too, under the diesel, thick and close in that little space, and I knelt with my back to the bulkhead and pulled kelp out of the strainer with my hands shaking.
The lightning smell came up through the bilge. The two of them together. I've never smelled anything like it since and I hope I never do.
Kyle came down the ladder about midnight and crouched beside me.
"I'm going to say something," he said. "And I want you to listen to me."
"Okay."
"We cut it. Before the slack. Not just the cedar. All of it. The whole towline, right at the bitt. Let it all go."
"Vic's sitting on it."
"Vic's going to fall asleep sometime." He was whispering, even though the engine was loud enough to cover a shout. "Owen, your dad said give it back. You told me. We're not going anywhere with that thing. You know we're not."
I thought about Ray Dunn walking up past that stump into the dark without a light. Three days, my dad had said. This was our third night.
I thought about my hands on the saw.
"There's an axe in the wheelhouse," I said. "On the bracket behind the chart table. Next time I go up, I'll get it. You take the wheel. When the slack comes, before we run the bar, I go aft and I put it through the line."
"And Vic?"
"Vic can swim after it if he wants."
I said that. I'm not proud of it.
At three in the morning I climbed up out of the engine room with the kelp bucket in one hand, and set it down by the wheelhouse door, and reached behind the chart table for the axe.
The bracket was empty.
"Looking for this?"
Vic was standing in the doorway behind me with the rain running off his hood. He had the axe in his right hand, hanging down by his leg.
I hadn't heard him come in. Kyle was at the bottom of the ladder looking up, his face white in the red engine-room light.
"Vic," I said.
"I heard you." He didn't raise his voice. "Down there. Talking about my tow."
"We're not getting home with it. You know that. You knew it yesterday. You knew it when you wouldn't look at the trees."
He smiled. It wasn't his smile. It was too slow.
"It came back to us," he said. "Owen. You saw. The chain opened and it didn't drift away. It came back. Right up to the boat. It wants to come with us. Why would I let it go?"
"That isn't what that means."
"Forty grand." He said it softly, like he was saying somebody's name. "I've got forty thousand dollars sitting off my stern. I've worked thirty years for a log like that."
Under us, the hull boomed. The whole boat heeled. Vic didn't put out a hand to steady himself. He just leaned with it and came back upright, still smiling.
"Anybody touches my line," he said, "I'll put them ashore right here. On that beach. You can walk home."
He looked past me through the rain-streaked window at the black treeline.
Then he turned and went back out to his chair on the stern, carrying the axe.
I stood in the wheelhouse a long time. Then I reached down and felt the dive knife, still strapped to my calf under the leg of my rain pants, where I'd strapped it after I got out of the suit.
The wind was still screaming. The dawn slack was four hours off.
Nobody slept. At five the rain thinned out to a drizzle and the dark started going grey over the hills behind the bight. The wind was still blowing hard, but the gusts had a space between them now. With the Danforth dragging and no shelter on that side, it was the bar or the beach.
Kyle hauled the Danforth by hand. It came up clean.
"Take her," I told him. I needed my hands free for whatever came. Kyle had run the Rose across the bar with Vic all summer. He went into the wheelhouse and put his hands on the wheel. I stood in the doorway beside him. My dad's saw was in its wooden case under the chart table, by my feet. I don't know why I'd moved it there in the night. I'd just wanted it close.
Vic stayed in his chair on the stern. Axe across his knees. He'd taken off his float coat to sit in the rain. It was lying beside his chair. Flashlight off now. The cedar rode two meters behind him, upright, pale end up. The other five logs trailed out behind on the towline, rising and falling on the swell.
Kyle eased her out of the bight at three knots. The temperature needle sat just under the red. We came around the point and the full swell picked us up, long and grey and heavy, coming in from the west under the wind. An hour and a half of that, crawling east past Cape Sutil, before I could see the bar ahead, across the mouth of the channel. A line of white where the seas stood up on the shallows, breaking and falling and breaking again. On the slack it should lie down enough to cross. Barely.
"Slack's in twenty minutes," Kyle said. "We'll be right on it."
We were halfway there when the engine stopped.
No cough this time. It just quit, and the silence came in behind it, and the Rose fell off the wind and began to roll.
Kyle hit the starter. It turned over and didn't catch. He hit it again.
"Strainer," I said, and started for the hatch.
"Owen." Kyle's voice was very quiet. "Look at the water."
The wind was still screaming. I could hear it in the rigging. But around the Rose, in a circle maybe a hundred meters across, the sea had gone flat. Not calm. Flat. The swell came in from the west, big and grey, and when it reached the edge of that circle it simply stopped. Inside, the water was smooth as glass and dark as oil, and the Rose sat in the middle of it without moving at all.
The smell came up all around us. Lightning, and rain on hot rock.
And from the shore, at the same time, the musk.
I looked toward Cape Sutil. Toward the timber standing above the rocks.
It was there.
For the first time it wasn't between the trunks. It was standing out in front of them, at the very edge of the trees, on the bare rock above the tide. Tall. Much taller than a man. Dark all the way through, so dark that the trees behind it looked pale. It didn't skip. It didn't move at all. It stood there, and I knew with my whole body that it was looking at the boat.
Beside us, the water rose.
It came up slow. That's what I remember most. No splash. The glassy surface bulged off the starboard side, long and low, and kept bulging, and then broke open and something came up out of it and kept coming.
It was a back. That's the only word I have. It ran the length of the boat and past both ends, grey and brown and ridged, crusted with barnacle, with long strips hanging off it that looked like old cedar bark, soaked black. It was like seeing a whole stretch of beach turned up on its side. Water sheeted off it with no sound. It was close enough that I could have reached out and touched it.
At the near end something lifted. Something that might have been a head.
It turned.
It didn't turn toward me. It didn't turn toward Kyle in the wheelhouse, or Vic in his chair. It turned toward the stern. Toward the cedar.
It was waiting.
I don't know how long we stood there. Vic was on his feet. The axe had slid off his knees onto the deck. He was staring at that back with his mouth open, and his face was the face of a man who'd spent thirty years on the water and had just found out he knew nothing about it.
My dad's voice. You give it back.
Vic's voice. It was your saw.
I went aft.
I didn't run. The deck was steady under me for the first time in two days. I knelt at the towing bitt, the steel post the line is made fast to, where it came over the stern. Three-quarter-inch poly, wet and hard. I pulled up the leg of my rain pants and slid the dive knife out of its sheath.
"Owen," Vic said. Not shouting. Almost pleading. "Owen, don't."
I put the blade to the line and sawed.
The strands parted one at a time. I could feel every one go. The thing beside us didn't move. On the shore the shape didn't move. Vic took one step toward me and stopped, and I don't know if it was me that stopped him or what was in the water.
The last strand let go.
The towline slithered off the stern and over the side. The five logs at the end of it swung loose. And the cedar, which had been riding upright all night, leaned slowly over and lay down flat on the glassy water, long and gold and raw-ended, its dogs and chains trailing off it.
I stood up. My legs were shaking.
Then I went back to the wheelhouse and pulled my father's saw out from under the chart table. I opened the case. The orange body, the bar I'd filed four strokes a tooth. I'd rebuilt that carburetor with my own hands. I'd promised him I'd bring it back.
I carried it to the stern and threw it into the sea.
It went in beside the cedar, right by the cut end, and sank without a ripple. I watched it go down through the dark water until I couldn't see it.
The head turned. Just slightly. Toward the place where the saw went in. Then back toward the log.
That's when Vic moved.
He had the dog bag open on the deck. I hadn't seen him go to it. He came up with a log dog in one hand and a sledge in the other, and he ran for the stern rail.
"Vic! No!"
He was over it. He jumped the gap and landed on the cedar on his hands and knees, and the log hardly dipped under him. He knelt up and set the spike of the dog against the wood and swung the sledge, once, twice, driving it in. The chain on the dog was in his fist. He was reaching back toward the boat with it. Toward me.
"Take it!" he was shouting. "Take the chain, Owen! Get a line on it! It's forty—"
The cedar rolled.
It didn't roll fast. It turned over in the water the way you'd turn over in your sleep, slow and heavy and complete. Vic went over with it. There was no splash. His orange rain jacket went under the glassy surface and the log came up on the other side, gold and wet and bare.
He didn't come up.
Kyle was out of the wheelhouse with the life ring. He threw it to where Vic had gone in. It floated there, turning slowly. We stood at the rail and stared at the water and waited.
Nothing.
The thing beside us was gone. I didn't see it go. The water where it had been was just water.
And the cedar was moving.
It was going west. Into the swell. Against the wind, against the current. Not drifting. Travelling, end-first, steady as a boat under power, back the way we'd come. Back toward Cape Scott. The four loose logs were already scattering east toward the bar where the sea wanted them, and the cedar went the other way, all by itself, getting smaller.
On the shore at Cape Sutil, the shape was gone. Just trees.
The musk was gone. The lightning smell was gone. There was only salt and diesel and rain.
And the circle broke.
The swell came in across the glassy water and lifted the Rose and dropped her hard, and the wind hit us full on the beam, and through the wheelhouse window I saw how close we'd drifted. The bar was right there. White water standing up a few hundred meters off the bow.
"Kyle!"
He was already moving. He dove into the wheelhouse and hit the starter.
She caught on the first turn. Ran smooth. The temperature needle dropped back to the middle and stayed there.
Kyle put her in gear and swung the bow toward the bar. The slack was on. The swell was still big, but the ebb had stopped pushing it up, and the breaking had eased into long heaving hills. He sat watching them come, three, four, then gunned her into the gap behind the biggest one and rode its back across the shallows. Water came green over the bow. The Rose climbed and fell and climbed. Kyle didn't say one word. He just drove.
Then the swell lengthened, and the water went from white to grey, and we were across.
I looked back once, from the stern.
Far to the west, under the low cloud, there was a small gold line on the water, still going.
Kyle was on sixteen calling Mayday before Vic's jacket was out of sight. Nothing but hiss. It didn't come back till Hope Island. Then Coast Guard out of Prince Rupert came back clear as a bell, and he told them we'd lost a man overboard crossing Nahwitti Bar. That was true. It just wasn't all of it.
They searched for two days. A lifeboat out of Port Hardy and a Cormorant out of Comox. They found the life ring. They never found Vic.
They asked plenty. The RCMP, the coroner, a man from WorkSafe. Where's the main anchor, where's the tow. We said we cut the tow loose to get over the bar in the swell, and that was true too. Nobody asked about a cedar. A man goes over on Nahwitti in a westerly, and on that coast nobody needs it explained.
Kyle tied the Rose up at the government wharf in Hardy, shut down the engine, and sat in the wheelhouse a long time with his hands in his lap. He quit salvage that week. Last I heard he was working on a whale-watching boat out of Telegraph Cove. I hope they come close for him.
I didn't wash. I drove straight home. Ruth met me at the door and held on to me without a word, and then she stepped aside.
My dad was in his chair by the window. Feet in the basin. He looked smaller than he had four days before.
I knelt down in front of him. I told him about the saw. That I'd thrown it in. That I was sorry.
He didn't say anything. He reached out and took both my hands in his, turned them palm up, and brought them to his face. He held them there and breathed in, slow, once, the way you'd check a log for rot.
Then he let go, and put his hand on my head, and looked out the window at the water. He never said a word about it again. He passed the next spring.
I stayed on. Another outfit, another skipper, a good one who doesn't cut corners. I still go out past the bar most weeks. And I still do the things that brought me home.
Below the tide line. Nothing with roots. And smell the wind before you step ashore.
Most mornings my hands smell of nothing but coffee and diesel. But some mornings, before I'm properly awake, I'll lift them to rub my face and it's there. Thick, and rank, and faint, under the skin.
Ruth says she can't smell anything.
I wash my hands, and I go to work.
